title box

445 S. Jefferson Route 42
Plain City, Ohio 43064
614 873 3414

 

View Hours of Operation

Cream pies in our bakery

Der Dutchman Bakery {PLAIN CITY}

Inside the bright, spacious bakery attached to Der Dutchman Restaurant, there’s a wide window behind the counter with a view of the kitchen. Amid the racks of cooling cookies, home-style fruit pies, and blueberry muffins, there’s plenty of activity to watch all day long. But you’d have to be there in the middle of the night to really get a glimpse of this busy bakery in action.

Photo of several cinnamon twists donuts

Sweet Dreams

In the wee hours, the irresistible aroma of buttery, sweet cinnamon rolls fresh from the oven advertises that the bakers are hard at work. While Plain City sleeps, they’re busy baking nearly ten different kinds of bread and rolls, glazing dozens of apple fritters, putting the finishing touches on our famous cream sticks, making hundreds of muffins, and crowning the cinnamon rolls with a swirl of creamy white or caramel icing.

When the doors of the bakery open at 5 in the morning, the shelves and cases are filled with the fruits of their overnight labor. Stop in for a sweet start to your day and order a fresh-brewed cup of coffee or a specialty coffee drink from the corner coffee shop, conveniently located right inside the bakery. Enjoy your breakfast treat and coffee at a café table or take it to go.

Photo of food-to-go in a dairy case

Delicious Treats All Day

The coffee shop is open all day, so you can enjoy a pick-me-up anytime or sip your favorite coffee drink before or after a meal at the restaurant. Just be forewarned that you might find it impossible to resist sampling some of our wonderful baked goods, too! You’ll see snickerdoodles flecked with cinnamon, iced buttermilk cookies, classic German chocolate cake with rich coconut topping, airy angel food cakes, and nearly 20 varieties of our legendary homemade pies, in both family and individual-serving sizes.

Mixed from scratch, fluted by hand, and baked on the premises every day, Der Dutchman’s line-up of pies includes crumb-topped Dutch apple, black raspberry, pecan, custard, lemon meringue, and the uniquely Amish peanut butter cream. If you spot one of our famous fresh fruit pies in the bakery case—spring rhubarb, June strawberry, or summer peach—take advantage of your good fortune. These specialty pies are always popular, but they’re available only for a brief time, when the fruits are in season.

Pies in Bakery

So Much To Enjoy

Der Dutchman Bakery also carries a wide variety of specialty foods. Shelves and cases are stocked with jars of fruit preserves, homemade noodles, salads, cheeses, meats, and jars of Der Dutchman Apple Butter and Amish Peanut Butter Spread that are perfect for taking the flavor of Amish Country home with you.

In addition to the bakery, the Der Dutchman building in Plain City also offers visitors an opportunity to sample authentic Amish Kitchen Cooking at Der Dutchman Restaurant and browse two floors of beautiful gifts and home décor at Carlisle Gifts. It’s all right there for you to enjoy, with plenty of parking, easy access, and genuine country hospitality.

Back to top

Bakery Delivery in the greater Columbus area
What to do in Plain City, Ohio