Dining

Savor Amish Country Flavor

One of the nicest parts about staying at the Carlisle Inn is dining with our next-door neighbor—Dutch Valley Restaurant—and enjoying its authentic Amish Kitchen Cooking. The menu offers exactly the kind of simple, satisfying cooking you’d expect to find in a farmhouse kitchen—big country breakfasts, hearty homemade soups, a bountiful all-you-can-eat salad bar, kid-pleasing favorites, and generous home-style entrees served with a choice of sides, including real mashed potatoes smothered in gravy. Homemade pies and pastries from the bakery always leave diners with a sweet taste in their mouths.