Exterior of Carlisle Inn, Sugarcreek

Hear from Guest, Sugarcreek

Hear from Guests

"We have stayed in hotels all over the world—London, Singapore, Thailand, France, Kenya, Paris, etc. None are more inviting than this one with its spacious, beautifully appointed rooms and friendly staff. I’m sure we’ll be back as often as we can. Thank you for a wonderful stay."

"I've wanted to stay at the Carlisle ever since they started building it. I finally got the opportunity and wasn't disappointed! We only stayed one night, but were so impressed we'll certainly stay there often now."

"This place is beautiful and everything I'd hoped it would be. The staff was friendly and helpful while we were there. Their continental breakfast served on the second floor is what most restaurants would consider a full breakfast! On the morning we were there, they had toast, bagels, waffles, hot sausage, different types of hot and cold cereal, fruit salad, and other things I'm sure I didn't even notice. I've been eating at the restaurant next door for years and I highly recommend it. Go for the family dining. Each person gets drinks, salad bar, all you can eat main course, and dessert for a decent price. They'll keep filling those plates as fast as you can empty them. Make sure to give the pie a try, it's delicious. My favorite will always be the Peanut Butter Cream. Wouldn't be a trip to Sugarcreek without it."

"The hotel was very peaceful and quiet, exceeding all our expectations of it. We're going back to stay this weekend!" — Clarksburg,WVA

"We have traveled in 45 of the states, stayed at hundreds of inns, hotels, etc – this is THE BEST! Superior accommodations!" — Milwaukee, WI

"We stayed for the weekend. Great decor, I wish I had all of these furnishings in my own home. The space was great. The space to lounge and gather in groups was really great for our group. We were treated by someone that stopped by to play the piano in the lounge area as well. They also offer complimentary coffee and tea all night and day. It really had nice rooms with different styles in all of the rooms that our group had rented. This made it a little more special. I think that the hotel was nicer than most of the hotels that I have stayed at, for a price that matched others. Good job with this hotel layout!" — Grove City, Ohio

"We stayed at the Carlisle Inn and it was wonderful. The rooms were large and really furnished beautifully. My grandchildren loved the pool. The staff was very friendly. We are planning on going back. You can walk from the inn to an Amish Restaurant, a gift shop, a furniture store, and a bulk food store so it was very convenient. They had a Continental Breakfast that was served in this beautiful room that made you feel like you were out in the garden eating." — Chagrin Falls, Ohio

"The service, hospitality and facilities here are 5-star excellent! Thank you for the effort."
— Pickerington, Ohio

"Lovely inn-has convenience I enjoy while maintaining a cozy feeling."
— East Liberty Ohio

"Very clean and relaxing. We stayed many places. Friendliest staff by far. Thank you."
— Mentor, Ohio

"Great place for families." — Mason, Ohio

We have stayed in two suites and they are all beautiful! I like the variety of each room.
— Wintersville, Ohio

"This is really a great place to relax and stay. We will definitely return in the future!"
— Fredericktown, Ohio

"We stay at your inn every time we’re in Ohio. We love it!" — DuBois, PA

I have never stayed in a cleaner, more beautiful room in my life. Thank you!— Moundsville, WV

Our first time here, but we will be back. What a beautiful place! And so peaceful and the library is wonderful. We liked the classical music. — Massillon, Ohio

Back to top