Amish Gift Store

Photo-Lace display at a Carlisle Gift Shop

Shopping opportunities abound in Amish Country, but at Carlisle Gifts, the experience is truly delightful. Charming shops in each of our locations compliment the unique, rural culture while offering a wide variety of quality items that celebrate home, family, friendship, and beauty. • • • At Carlisle Gifts, customers can discover something new— creative gifts, home accessories, jewelry, collectibles, books, toys, and more—and the pleasure of leisure-time shopping in a scenic rural setting.

Illustration-Hoosier cabinet with decorative items

Map of Ohio showing the location of all the Dutchman gift shops

1. Carlisle Gifts - Walnut Creek
4962 Walnut Street
Walnut Creek, Ohio 44687
330 893 2535

2. Dutch Valley Market - Sugarcreek
1411 Old Route 39
Sugarcreek, Ohio 44681
330 852 2631

2. Dutch Valley Gifts - Sugarcreek
1367 Old Route 39
Sugarcreek, Ohio 44681
330 852 4926

2. Dutch Valley Furniture - Sugarcreek
1373 Old Route 39
Sugarcreek, Ohio 44681
330 852 4026

3. Carlisle Gifts - Plain City
445 S. Jefferson Route 42
Plain City, Ohio 43064
614 837 1332

4. Carlisle Furniture and Gifts - Waynesville
188 North US Route 42
Waynesville, Ohio 45068
513 897 3791

"What an unexpected experience to shop at Carlisle Gifts. I felt inspired! I got dozens of great new gift ideas and the clever furniture arrangements helped me figure out a creative solution for my dining room. Thanks."
— an inspired customer