• Ordering Information

• Order FAQ
• Order Status
• Policies
• Privacy and Security
• Contact Us

• Sharing

• Print This Page
• Send to Friend

Home > Pantry and Specialties > Der Dutchman Peanut Butter Spread

Der Dutchman Peanut Butter Spread

$4.99 - $46.99

Meet your new comfort food. Thick, sweet, and creamy, Amish peanut butter spread is perfect on homemade bread. A Holmes County favorite, this simple snack alternative to peanut butter and jelly is very popular with locals and visitors alike.

Comes in 19 oz squeeze bottles.

A Great Pair

There are some things that just go together - and our breads and Amish peanut butter spread are no exception. Peanut butter spread, sometimes referred to as “church spread,” differs greatly from typical national-name-brand peanut butter. Made with marshmallow cream and sweet syrup, Amish peanut butter is lighter and sweeter, making it seem more like a dessert spread than the pantry staple most modern households stock.

But why the “church spread” alias? In the Amish community, Sundays are kept sacred as the Sabbath – a day of worship and rest from work. That means no cooking. After the Amish have gathered for church services, which can last three hours, a light lunch is served. A typical Sunday church meal might include homemade bread with Amish peanut butter spread, butter, or jam; plus red beets, pickles, cheese, cookies, and leftovers that need no preparation.


Buy dinner rolls or bread