Search
Menu

BAKERY

Long before our 5am opening, our bakers are up making, baking and glazing 10 kinds of breads and rolls, 20 varieties of fruit, cream and crumb pies, dozens of apple fritters, and an array of other from-scratch, hand-fluted goodies.

July Bakery Specials

July Bakery Specials

Fresh Strawberry Pie through July 8

-

Strawberry Banana Cream Pie through July 8

-

Rhubarb Pie through July 8

-

Strawberry Rhubarb Pie through July 8

-

Key Lime Pie

-

Summer Cut Out Cookies

-

Fresh Blueberry Lemon Pie

-

Fresh Peach Pie
Available July 10 to August 5

 

 

 

 

 

Fresh Peach Pie
 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Bakery Menu

Pastries

Apple Fritter
Cinnamon Roll
Long John
Donut twists
Crullers
Jelly-filled donuts
Pecan Roll
Glazed Donuts

Cake-style Donuts
Chocolate, Vanilla, Pumpkin, Blueberry

 

Muffins

Cranberry
Lemon Poppyseed
Blueberry
Pumpkin
Bran
Chocolate
Coffee Cake

 

Pantry Favorites

Noodles
Amish Peanut Butter Spread
Apple Butter
Jams, Jellies & Preserves
Granola
Croutons
Fudge
Mush
Bread Pudding
Cheese Spread
Cold Cut Meats and Cheeses

Pies

Fruit Pie 

Black Raspberry
Blackberry
Blueberry
Cherry*
Peach
Apple*
Dutch Apple
Raisin

Specialty Pie

Sugar Cream
Custard
Lemon Meringue
Pecan
German Chocolate

Cream Pie

Coconut Cream*
Peanut Butter Cream
Chocolate Cream
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream
Banana Cream*
Butterscotch Cream
Red Raspberry Cream
Black Raspberry Cream

Seasonal Pie

Fresh Summer Peach
Fresh Strawberry
Rhubarb
Grape
Mincemeat
Pumpkin*
Strawberry Banana
Strawberry Rhubarb

* Also available with no added sugar

Whoopie Pies

Chocolate
Pumpkin

Breads

Whole Wheat**
White**
Cinnamon
Raisin
Apple Butter
Pumpernickel
Muesli
Rye
Sourdough
Banana
Pumpkin
English Muffin
Garlic Pull-a-Part
Focaccia

** Loaves, rolls, & sandwich buns

 

Cakes

Angel Food
Vanilla
Chocolate
Carrot
German Chocolate
Pumpkin Roll
Chocolate Roll
Chocolate Honey Cream
Apple Honey Cream
Cherry Honey Cream
Peach Honey Cream
Pecan Honey Cream

Special Order

Birthday Cakes

Cookies

Buttermilk
Chocolate Chip
Coconut
Honey Nut Raisin
Monster
Peanut Butter
Chocolate Crinkle
Raisin Oatmeal
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Snicker Doodle
Sugar
Oatmeal
No-Bake cookies
Raisin-filled
Raspberry Shortbread
Pumpkin

Cookie Dough

Cookie Bars

Lemon Bars
Heavenly Bars
Brownies
Mint Brownies
Double deck Brownies

Carry-Out

The Bakery offers carry-out service for all items on the Der Dutchman breakfast, lunch, and dinner menu.

Call ahead. 614-873-3414

Bakery Partners

Der Dutchman baked goods are available or served at these establishments in the Columbus area. Find our partners

 

The Andersons Store

7000 Bent Tree Blvd
Columbus, Ohio
937-642-0363 | Website

 

Amish Heritage Country Market

728 North Main St
Marysville, Ohio
614-766-9500 | Website

 

The Best Breakfast and Sandwiches
5916 Westerville Rd
Westerville, Ohio
614-776-5788


Bridgewater Banquet and Conference Center

10651 Sawmill Pkwy
Powell, Ohio
614-734-9800 | Website

 

Caffe Tomaso
5455 Rings Ave
Dublin, Ohio
614-761-8425

 

CJs Market
5 S Mill St
Milford Center, Ohio
937-349-4015

Columbus Convention Center
400 N High St.
Columbus, Ohio
614-827-2500 | Website

 

Corner Carry Out
537 S Maple St
Marysville, Ohio
937-642-2933

 

Freeman’s Market

6146 Lewis Center Rd
Galena, Ohio
740-548-1149

First Community Village
1800 Riverside Dr
Columbus, Ohio
614-324-4455 | Website


Grand Day Cafe

1284 West 5th Ave
Columbus, Ohio
614-481-3363

 

Hickory House
550 Officenter Pl
Gahanna, Ohio
614-428-7427

7051 E Main St
Reynoldsburg, Ohio
614-861-5962 | Website


Jimmy V's Grill and Pub
1 South State St
Westerville, Ohio
614-865-9090 | Website

 

The Hills Market
7860 Olentangy River Rd
Columbus, Ohio
614-846-3220

95 North Grant
Columbus, Ohio
614-985-1440 | Website

 

Huffman’s Market
2140 Tremont Center
Columbus, Ohio
614-486-5336 | Website

 

Kuhlweins Farm Market
1859 Walker Rd
Hilliard, Ohio
614-876-2833

 

Larry Bs Meat & Cheese
203 West Main St
West Jefferson, Ohio
614-879-6000

 

Lilys Kitchen Table
4008 Broadway
Grove City, Ohio
614-801-0771 | Website

 

Luckys Market
2768 North High St
Columbus, Ohio
614-447-0258

 

Madriver Farm Market
7538 US Highway 68 North
West Liberty, Ohio
937-465-2030

 

Marathon
4400 Roberts Rd
Columbus, Ohio
614-771-0204

Marathon
215 West Bridge St
Dublin, Ohio
614-889-1860

 

Marathon
7810 Olentangy River Rd
Worthington, Ohio
614-846-8443

 

McAuliffes
1299 West 5th St
Marysville, Ohio
937-642-2891

 

Mid-way Market (Shell)
8208 Marysville Rd
Ostrander, Ohio
740-666-4935

 

Miller’s Country Gardens
2488 West State Rt 37
Delaware, Ohio
740-363-5021 | Website

 

Mosier’s IGA
21701 Main St
Raymond, Ohio
937-246-3772

 

New Era Market
7775 Dublin Rd
Powell, Ohio
740-881-4142

 

New Grounds Coffee House
6318 Scioto Darby Rd
Hilliard, Ohio
614-876-9246

 

Phillips Coney Island
450 West Broad St
Columbus, Ohio
614-221-8288

 

Pilot
1365 Northeast State Route 42
London, Ohio
740-879-4128

 

Pilot
3600 Interchange Rd
Columbus, Ohio
614-308-9195

 

The Pit Stop
23255 State Route 4
Marysville, Ohio
937-578-0023

Putt-N-Play
4021 Thislewood Dr
Grove City, Ohio
614-594-0077

 

Red Door Tavern
1736 West 5th Ave
Columbus, Ohio 
614-488-5433 | Website


Rhodes Tower Cafe

30 East Broad St
Columbus, Ohio
614-752-8381


Rife Tower Cafe
77 South High St
Columbus, Ohio
614-460-7211

 

Schumans Meats
1440 Harrisburg Pike
Columbus, Ohio
614-274-2161 | Website

 

Scioto Downs
6000 S High St
Columbus, Ohio
614-295-4700

 

Shell
3088 Broadway
Grove City, Ohio 
614-871-5070

 

South of Lane
1987 Guilford Rd
Upper Arlington, Ohio
614-586-2233

 

Sunoco
648 Grandview Ave
Columbus, Ohio 
614-488-2464

 

Uptown Deli and Brew
41 North State St
Westerville, Ohio
614-891-2337 | Website

 

Village Mart Marathon
10152 State Route 42
Marysville, Ohio
614-873-4855

 

Weilands Market
3600 Indianola Ave
Columbus, Ohio
614-267- 9878 | Website


Winans Fine Chocolates and Coffee
52 South High St
Dublin, Ohio
614-766-7061 | Website

3425 Morse Crossing
Columbus, Ohio

 

Yutzy’s Cheese House
1522 East State Route 36
Urbana, Ohio
937-653-4282 | Website

BANQUETS AND CATERING

From corporate meetings to weddings to community and family groups, we make every event a special occasion. Close to central Ohio and just outside Columbus, groups and guests appreciate gathering in a delightfully furnished and spacious facility with rural charm and gracious service.

Banquets
GROUP-FRIENDLY AMENITIES

Our excellent facilities and experienced staff members ensure that your events will be easy to plan, productive and memorable.

  • Rooms with flexible seating for 20 to 425
  • Private entrance, parking, coat area and restrooms
  • Hot, freshly prepared foods served quickly and efficiently
  • Breakfast, Appetizer, Family-style and Buffet options
  • Full audio/visual capabilities and excellent sound system
  • Smoke-free facilities
  • Alcoholic beverages are not permitted in banquet facilities or meeting rooms

For more information, please call 614-873-3414.

Motor Coach Tours
TOUR-FRIENDLY EXTRAS

Our reasonable prices and long list of amenities make this an easy way to experience the simple pleasures of small-town Plain City.

  • Easy, no-step access
  • Ample, free bus parking
  • Free meal and bakery item for driver and escort
  • Clean, convenient restrooms
  • Spacious dining rooms

For more information, please call 614-873-3414.

Wedding Receptions

Thanks to our family-friendly venue and charming surroundings, you can have the romantic country wedding reception of your dreams.

  • Attractive banquet rooms in various sizes and styles
  • Dinner for up to 400 or more intimate occasions
  • Audio/visual equipment
  • No-step access
  • Designated restrooms and lounge areas
  • Ample parking
  • Smoke-free facilities
  • Alcoholic beverages are not served or permitted in banquet facilities or meeting rooms

For more information, please call 614-873-3414.

Community & Family Groups
FAMILY-FRIENDLY AMENITIES

Plan your next event at a place that shares your values on family, faith and fellowship. Der Dutchman Restaurant extends a warm welcome to everyone from community and non-profit organizations to church groups and families.

  • Clean, safe environment
  • Friendly, efficient service
  • Quality, consistency and value
  • Non-smoking, alcohol-free facilities
  • Ample, free parking
  • Handicapped accessibility
  • Kid-friendly service
Off-Site Catering

For more than 20 years, the quality and goodness known to Central Ohio as Der Dutchman Restaurant has attracted patrons from far and wide. But you don’t have to travel to Plain City to experience the simple pleasures of our authentic Amish Kitchen Cooking. We also offer full-service catering that delivers our delicious, made-from-scratch food directly to your business event, wedding reception, or special occasion, along with exceptional value and attentive service.

 

Crowd-pleasing flavors

What makes the Der Dutchman catering experience so special? For starters, you can taste the tradition. The cooks in our kitchen use time-honored methods to create exactly the kind of simple, flavorful foods that lend themselves to feeding and satisfying a crowd.

Specially seasoned, all-natural meats roasted, broasted, and slow-cooked to tender perfection and served piping hot. Plates piled high with savory, made-from-scratch side dishes, like classic bread stuffing, real mashed potatoes and gravy, or homemade egg noodles. Slow-simmered soups, garden-fresh salads, and sandwiches made with just-baked breads and rolls. And there’s always a selection of our famous homemade pies and pastries, for a sweet finish from the Der Dutchman Bakery.
 

Options for every occasion

Our catering menu offers abundant options for bringing the delicious Der Dutchman experience to events of all types and sizes, day or night. The selection ranges from tasty appetizer platters and cheese trays to hearty boxed lunches, family-style meals, and, of course, our country buffets for breakfast, lunch, or dinner.

Our special wedding package presents a choice of menus perfect for sharing with family and friends on this joyous occasion.

Whatever the event, our trained servers are there to set up the food table, assist during the meal, and take care of the details so the hosts can relax and enjoy the event knowing every guest is well taken care of.

wide.jpg

DIRECTIONS

From the North via I-71 (Cleveland, Mansfield)
From I-71, at the north side of Columbus, take I-270 West. At exit #17B, take Route 33 and State Route 161 West, which run together for a number of miles. Follow 161 West to Route 42 in Plain City. Follow Route 42 South, making sure to continue on 42 as it takes a sharp left on the west edge of town. Shortly after the sharp left, the Der Dutchman/Carlisle Gifts complex will be visible on the left.
Der Dutchman Restaurant & Bakery
445 S. Jefferson Ave.
Plain City, OH 43064
614-873-3414
Carlisle Gifts
445 S. Jefferson Ave.
Plain City, OH 43064
614-873-1332

From the East or West via I-70 (Dayton, Springfield, Wheeling)
From I-70, take exit #79 and follow State Route 42 North about 13 miles up the road to the Der Dutchman/Carlisle Gifts complex on the right.
Der Dutchman Restaurant & Bakery
445 S. Jefferson Ave.
Plain City, OH 43064
614-873-3414
Carlisle Gifts
445 S. Jefferson Ave.
Plain City, OH 43064
614-873-1332

From the South via I-71 (Cincinnati)
From I-71, take I-270 around the west side of Columbus. At exit #17B, take Route 33 and State Route 161 West, which run together for a number of miles. Follow 161 West to Route 42 in Plain City. Follow Route 42 South, making sure to continue on 42 as it takes a sharp left on the south edge of town. Der Dutchman/Carlisle Gifts complex is on the left.
Der Dutchman Restaurant & Bakery
445 S. Jefferson Ave.
Plain City, OH 43064
614-873-3414
Carlisle Gifts
445 S. Jefferson Ave.
Plain City, OH 43064
614-873-1332

HOURS

Regular Hours

Der Dutchman Restaurant & Bakery 

Monday–Thursday: 6am–8pm
Friday and Saturday: 6am–9pm
Sunday: Closed 

 

 

Carlisle Gifts 

Monday–Thursday: 8am–8pm
Friday and Saturday: 8am–9pm
Sunday: Closed 

Holiday Hours

CHRISTMAS EVE 2016

6am–2pm

 

CHRISTMAS DAY 2016

Closed

 

NEW YEAR'S EVE 2016

6am–7pm

 

NEW YEAR'S DAY 2017

Closed

 

JANUARY 9

Closed

 

MEMORIAL DAY

6am–7pm

 

 

JULY 4

6am–7pm

 

Labor DAY

6am–7pm

 

thanksgiving eve

6am–8pm

 

 

 

 

THANKSGIVING DAY

Closed

 

CHRISTMAS EVE 2017

Closed

 

CHRISTMAS DAY 2017

Closed

NEW YEAR'S EVE 2017

Closed

 

NEW YEAR'S DAY 2018

Closed