FAMILY-STYLE MEALS
“Pass the potatoes!” Enjoy Amish-style foods served around the table the old-fashioned family way. Choose chicken, turkey, ham, or roast beef to go with a tossed salad, and delicious sides of homemade mashed potatoes, gravy, dressing, potato salad, coleslaw, creamed corn or green beans. Family-Style Meal also includes dinner rolls, beverage and a piece of pie.

3 Meats 18.99 | 2 Meats 17.99 | Chicken Only 16.29 | No Meat 14.99
Age 6-10 7.99 | Age 3-5 4.99 | Under 2 Free

Lunch & Dinners
Include homemade white or wheat dinner rolls and your choice of two side dishes.

Chicken

Broasted Chicken
Broasted chicken is marinated, breaded and broasted under pressure in trans fat-free oil — crispy outside, juicy inside.
3 pc Mixed — 1 Breast, 1 Leg, 1 Thigh 12.39
3 pc Dark — 1 Leg, 2 Thighs 12.39
2 pc Mixes — 1 Breast, 1 Leg 11.99
2 pc Dark — 1 Leg, 1 Thigh 11.79
2 pc White — 2 Breasts 13.49
1 pc White — 1 Breast 11.49

Charbroiled Chicken Breast
Boneless, marinated and charbroiled.
10 oz 13.99
5 oz 12.69

Turkey

Roast Turkey 12.69
Old-fashioned slow-roasted.
All white meat +1.99

Beef
We serve only Certified Angus Beef®.

Old-fashioned Roast Beef 12.99
Amish-style, chuck roast, slow-roasted in its own juices.

Liver & Onions
Grilled baby beef liver served with sautéed glazed onions.
8 oz 12.39
4 oz 11.39

Homemade Meatloaf 12.59
Amish-style, slow cooked meatloaf.

Pork

Roast Pork 12.29
Slow-roasted to perfection in our own seasonings.

Grilled Ham 12.59
Thick slice of cured ham.

Fish & Seafood

Cod
Your choice preparation: steamed in butter, Cajun-style or battered.
1 piece 13.59
2 piece 12.59

Amish Country Sampler 14.99
Includes your choice of two meats, mashed potatoes, gravy, dressing, vegetable and tossed salad. Choose from chicken, roast beef, turkey or ham.
All white meat add 1.99

Sandwiches
Served on homemade breads or grilled buns — with your choice of one side dish.
With American, Swiss or Cheddar cheese +.59

Roast Beef 9.69

Turkey 9.39
With all white meat +1.39

Roast Pork 9.39
Juicy served on a homemade bun.

Manhattans Full 10.49 Half 9.49
Hot sandwich served with mashed potatoes and covered with gravy. Your choice of roast beef, turkey, or roast pork.
With all white meat +1.39

Fish 10.59
Cod, lightly battered and deep-fried.

Charbroiled Chicken 10.69
Boneless, skinless chicken breast, marinated and charbroiled to perfection. Topped with crisp lettuce, tomato and mayo.

Homemade Meatloaf 10.59
Amish style, slow-cooked meatloaf.

Amish Country Sampler 14.99
Includes your choice of two meats, mashed potatoes, gravy, dressing, vegetable and tossed salad. Choose from chicken, roast beef, turkey or ham.
All white meat add 1.99

Sandwiches
Served on homemade breads or grilled buns — with your choice of one side dish.
With American, Swiss or Cheddar cheese +.59

Roast Beef 9.69

Turkey 9.39
With all white meat +1.39

Roast Pork 9.39
Juicy served on a homemade bun.

Manhattans Full 10.49 Half 9.49
Hot sandwich served with mashed potatoes and covered with gravy. Your choice of roast beef, turkey, or roast pork.
With all white meat +1.39

Fish 10.59
Cod, lightly battered and deep-fried.

Charbroiled Chicken 10.69
Boneless, skinless chicken breast, marinated and charbroiled to perfection. Topped with crisp lettuce, tomato and mayo.

Homemade Meatloaf 10.59
Amish style, slow-cooked meatloaf.

Side Dishes

A la Carte 2.99
Baked Sweet
Potato (+.50)
Beets
Broccoli/Cauliflower Salad
Coleslaw
Creamed Corn
French Fries
Fresh Fruit (+.50)
Green Beans
Homemade Noodles
Mac & Cheese
Macaroni Salad
Potato Salad
Real Mashed
Potatoes & Gravy
Tossed Salad

Der Dutchman Salad Bar Plate 8.99

Missing our Salad Bar? We miss it too! However, Don’t Fret! We’ve developed an alternative we think you’ll enjoy!

Add the new Salad Bar Plate to any dinner for just 3.99

Or substitute it for one of your sides for just 1.99

Salad Bar Plate:
Freshly-prepared Tossed Salad with your choice of dressing, plus any 3 of your salad bar favorites from the options below
Choose From: Potato Salad, Macaroni Salad, Coleslaw, Broccoli/Cauliflower Salad, Cottage Cheese, Beets, Pie Surprise

Soups and Salads

Homemade Soup Bowl 4.29 Cup 3.29
Chicken Noodle or Beef Vegetable

Dressings: Sweet & Sour*, French*, Bleu Cheese*, Ranch, Italian, Poppy Seed*
*Denotes homemade salad dressings

Chef Salad 10.99
Fresh, crisp salad tossed with garden vegetables and topped with hardboiled egg, Colby cheese and croutons. Add your choice of chicken, ham, beef or turkey.

Strawberry Poppy Seed 11.99
Spinach and romaine lettuce, honey-roasted pecans, fresh strawberries, Feta cheese, and charbroiled marinated chicken breast; served with a poppy seed dressing.

Charbroiled Chicken Salad 11.59
Fresh, crisp salad tossed with garden vegetables and topped with shredded cheese blend. Topped with charbroiled marinated chicken breast.

Kid’s Menu
Served with choice of 2 sides.

Chicken 5.49
Choose two chicken fingers or two drumsticks.

Roast Turkey 5.49

Roast Beef 5.49

Corn Dog 4.49
Made with chicken franks.

Dutchman Desserts

Slice of Pie 3.99
Chocolate Cream, Coconut Cream, Cherry and Dutch Apple

Slice of Fresh Strawberry Pie 4.49

Beverages

Soft Drinks 2.79
Pepsi, *Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Diet Mountain Dew, Dr. Pepper, *Root Beer,*Sierra Mist, (*no caffeine). Free refills

Cold Drinks 2.79
Brisk Raspberry Tea, Pink Lemonade. Free refills

Freshly Brewed Iced Tea 2.79
Sweet Iced Tea, Unsweetened Iced Tea. Free refills

Juice 2.99
Orange, Apple, Tomato, Grape, Cranberry

Milk 2.89
White, Chocolate, Buttermilk

Fresh Ground Coffee 2.59
Regular or Decaffeinated, Free Refills

Hot Chocolate 2.89

Cappuccino 2.89

Bottled Water 1.59

Call 614-873-3414

We also offer a Catering Menu for orders of 10 or more. Click HERE for the menu.

Lunch & Dinner
11am-7pm. Served with two side dishes and a white or wheat roll.

Broasted Chicken 
3 pc mixed: 1 breast, 1 thigh, 1 leg $12.29
3 pc dark: 1 leg, 2 thighs $12.29
2 pc dark: 1 leg, 1 thigh $11.59
1 pc white: 1 breast $11.29

–

Roast Beef $12.99

–

Homemade Meatloaf $12.29

–

Roast Turkey $12.49

–

Roast Pork $12.29

–

2 Meat Sampler $14.59
Choose two of the meats from the options above and 4 side dishes.

Kid's Menu
Includes 2 sides

Chicken $5.39
Choice of 2 chicken fingers or drumsticks

–

Roast Turkey $5.39

–

Roast Beef $5.39

–

PB & J $1.00
Served with 1 side

Sandwiches
Comes with your choice of 1 side

Roast Beef $9.39

–

Turkey $8.99

–

Roast Pork $8.99

–

Manhattan $10.29
Turn any of the above options into a hot sandwich covered in gravy

–

Meatloaf $10.29

Buckets of Broasted Chicken
6 pc $10.89
9 pc $16.29
12 pc $19.99
15 pc $24.49
18 pc $28.49

meal packages

Family Meal for 4 $25.99
Your choice of 1 meat, 2 sides & dinner rolls. Perfect for a family of four!

Choose from Broasted Chicken (6pc), Slow-Roasted Turkey or Ham.

Choose 2 from: Mashed Potatoes with Gravy, Amish-Style Noodles, Green Beans or Corn.

Choose white or wheat dinner rolls.

–

Large Portions a la carte

Meats
Roast Beef $12.99 lb
Slow-Roasted Turkey $10.99 lb
Baked Ham $10.99 lb

Sides Serves 5-6 $7.49 qt
Mashed Potatoes w/ Gravy
Amish-Style Noodles
Green Beans
Creamed Corn
Coleslaw
Potato Salad
Macaroni Salad

–

Whole Pies
Cream Pies $10.99
Peanut Butter Cream Pie
Chocolate Cream Pie
Coconut Cream Pie

Fruit Pies $11.99
Dutch Apple Pie
Cherry Pie

Salads

Chef Salad $10.79
Your choice of chicken, ham, beef or turkey

–

Strawberry Poppy Seed Salad $11.49

Soups
Chicken Noodle or Vegetable Beef

Cup $3.29

–

Bowl $4.29

Sides

Noodles

Mashed Potatoes

Creamed Corn

Green Beans

Tossed Salad

Fresh Fruit

Potato Salad

Coleslaw

Macaroni Salad

Delivery
Online Ordering