Plain City, Ohio
Dine in or take home simple, classic tastes like hot roast pork sandwiches, broasted chicken, country ham, homemade rolls and noodles, peanut butter cream pie and dozens of other homemade selections.
Christmas Carry Out Package Deals
While we are closed on Christmas, you can still order Der Dutchman Carry Out for your meal at home. Ala carte ordering is available as well. Please place orders through Saturday, December 23 and bakery orders through Saturday, December 21, 2019. Meals will be fully-cooked and packed cold. Re-heating instructions will be included. Please place orders at 614-873-3414.
Serves 5 – $70.99
2 1/2 lbs turkey or ham
1 qt mashed potatoes
1 qt dressing (stuffing)
1 qt gravy
1 qt green beans or corn
1 doz dinner rolls (white or wheat)
1 freshly baked pie
Serves 10 – $128.99
5 lbs turkey or ham
2 qts mashed potatoes
2 qts dressing (stuffing)
1 qt gravy
2 qts green beans or corn
1 1/2 doz dinner rolls (white or wheat)
2 freshly baked pies
Serves 20 – $221.99
10 lbs turkey or ham
1 gal mashed potatoes
1 gal dressing (stuffing)
2 qts gravy
3 qts green beans or corn
3 doz dinner rolls (white or wheat)
4 freshly baked pies
Der Dutchman Favorites
Eggs & Toast
One or two eggs any style, served with toast
–
Der Dutchman Special
Two eggs served with hash browns, choice of meat and homemade toast; served with beverage.
–
Amish Scramble
Two eggs scrambled, choice of meat, hash browns, mushrooms, and onions; served with homemade toast and choice of cheese.
–
*Healthy Start
Country-style turkey sausage, Egg Beaters, fresh fruit cup and one piece of dry homemade toast.
480 calories / 12g fat / 1,120mg sodium / 50g carbs
–
Dutch Stack
Homemade toast piled high with scrambled eggs and hash browns, then smothered with sausage gravy.
–
Homemade Biscuits & Gravy
Creamy, homemade sausage or tomato gravy ladled over fresh-baked buttermilk biscuits.
–
Hash Browns & Gravy
Creamy, homemade sausage or tomato gravy ladled over hash browns.
–
Cornmeal Mush
Crispy golden slices of fried cornmeal mush served with warm syrup.
BREAKFAST BUFFET
Served Mon-Sat, 7:30am to 11am
Scrambled eggs, bacon, sausage, fried cornmeal mush, sausage gravy, biscuits, hash browns, pancakes, fresh pastries, fresh fruit, fruit slush, yogurt.
OMELETS
3-egg omelets served with homemade toast & hash browns.
Cheese Omelet
–
Western Omelet
Ham, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and cheese
–
Vegetarian Omelet
Onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and tomato
–
Country Omelet
Smoked sausage, green peppers, onions, and cheddar cheese
–
Spinach Omelet
Fresh spinach, diced tomatoes, onions and cheese
PanCAKES & More
Buttermilk Pancakes
–
Whole Wheat Pancakes
–
French Toast
Made with slices of our homemade bread and served with warm syrup.
–
Stuffed French Toast
Strawberry or Blueberry
Other Favorites
Egg & Cheese Sandwich
-
Fresh Fruit Parfait
Fresh fruit topped with vanilla or strawberry yogurt and our homemade granola; served with your choice of bread
-
Hot Oatmeal, Cream of Wheat or Grits
SIDES
Hash Browns
Potato Wedges
Sausage or Tomato Gravy
One Egg, any style
Ham, Bacon, Sausage, Smoked Sausage, or Turkey Sausage
Country Ham
Grits
Homemade Granola
Low-fat Strawberry Yogurt
Fresh Mixed Fruit
Bakery
Homemade Toast
White, Whole Wheat, Raisin, Rye, Sourdough, English Muffin
–
Iced Raisin Toast
–
Banana or Pumpkin Bread
–
Homemade Biscuits
–
Donuts
Cake, Sugared, Glazed
–
Pastries
Apple Fritter, Cinnamon Bun, Jelly-filled, Long Johns, Twists or Cruller
–
Cinnamon Roll
–
Pecan Roll
–
Muffin
Bran, Blueberry, Lemon Poppyseed, Pumpkin, Cranberry
–
English Muffin
–
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Plain, Blueberry, Raisin
Children’s Breakfast
Children 10 and under
One Egg & Toast
Served with 2 pieces bacon or 1 sausage patty
–
One Pancake
Served with 2 pieces bacon or 1 sausage patty
–
One Egg & Pancake
–
One Slice French Toast
Served with 2 pieces bacon or 1 sausage patty
Der Dutchman Salad Bar
Everyone enjoys a trip to our beautiful Salad Bar. As bountiful as a garden and as colorful as a quilt, the array includes fresh vegetables, prepared salads, and regional specialties that are constantly refilled and refreshed. We take pride in supporting our local growers and serve their fresh produce on our salad bar when in season.
Soup & Salad
Homemade Soup
Our soups are made daily. Ask your server about the soup of the day.
Vegetable Beef, Chicken Noodle, Beef Chili, Turkey Chili
–
Soup & Salad Bar
–
Chef Salad
Fresh, crisp salad tossed with garden vegetables and topped with hardboiled egg, and Colby cheese. Choose chicken, ham, turkey or roast beef.
–
Charbroiled Chicken Salad
Fresh, crisp salad tossed with garden vegetables and topped with Colby cheese and charbroiled marinated chicken breast.
–
Strawberry Crunch Salad
Fresh strawberries, toasted Ramen noodles, pecans, onions, and broccoli on a bed of fresh, crisp salad; served with a sweet vinaigrette dressing. Add marinated chicken breast.
–
Strawberry Poppyseed Salad
Spinach and romaine lettuce, honey-roasted pecans, fresh strawberries, Feta cheese, and charbroiled marinated chicken breast; served with a poppyseed dressing.
–
Apple Pecan Salad
Refreshing salad of Romaine and mixed greens with apples, honey-roasted pecans, bleu cheese and charbroiled marinated chicken breast; served with an apple cider vinaigrette dressing.
–
Meat-Lover's Salad
Spinach and iceburg lettuce with red onions, tomatoes, banana peppers, green olives, croutons and topped with charbroiled marinated chicken breast, ham and pepperoni.
Salad Dressings
House*, Ranch*, French*,Thousand Island, Italian,Blue Cheese*, Honey Mustard,Poppyseed*, Spicy Ranch, Vinegar & Oil, Raspberry Vinaigrette
*denotes our homemade dressings
FISH & SEAFOOD
Tilapia
6-8oz filet, broiled with our own seasoning
–
Cod
Mild cod, deep-fried with crispy breading
–
Shrimp
Eight butterfly shrimp lightly breaded and deep fried to perfection
–
Salmon
6-8oz filet, broiled tender
–
Seafood Platter
4oz cod and five pieces of butterfly shrimp
Dinners
Dinners include homemade dinner rolls and your choice of two side dishes. You may substitute salad bar for a side dish.
Barn Raising Buffet
The tradition of an Amish barn-raising meal or a Mennonite church potluck is all about coming together, sharing abundance, choosing as you go, and lots of variety! Here is our version: chicken, roast beef, ham, dressing, real mashed potatoes, noodles, corn, green beans, salad bar and more.
Lunch Buffet: Mon-Fri, except holidays, 11:30am to 4pm
Dinner Buffet: Mon-Fri, after 4pm
Saturday Buffet: Saturdays, 11am to Close
–
Amish Country Sampler
Sample our most popular menu items. Includes mashed potatoes, dressing, vegetable and tossed salad. Choose two meats – broasted or baked chicken, roast beef, ham or turkey.
Chicken
We serve Gerber's Amish Farm Chicken™. This chicken was fed a vegetarian diet with no antibiotics, no animal by-products, no growth stimulants and no added hormones.
Broasted Chicken
Marinated, breaded and broasted under pressure in trans fat-free oil – crispy outside, juicy inside.
–
Charbroiled Chicken Breast
Boneless, marinated in our own special seasoning
Turkey
Roast Turkey
Tender and juicy old-fashioned, slow-roasted turkey
Beef
We serve only Certified Angus Beef® brand beef
Old-Fashioned Roast Beef
Amish style slow-roasted in its own juices
–
Chopped Sirloin
Delicately seasoned and charbroiled
–
Meatloaf
Amish-style, freshly baked
–
Liver & Onions
Grilled beef liver served with sautéed onions
–
Swiss Steak
Pan-fried, baked in gravy
–
Country-fried Steak
Breaded and deep-fried, served with white pepper gravy
Pork
Grilled Ham
Thick slice cured ham
–
Pork Chops
Center cut bone-in pork chops, charbroiled
–
Roast Pork
Slow-cooked in our own seasonings
–
Country Smoked Sausage
Generous portion of mild smoked links
DUTCHMAN FAVORITES
Manhattan
Hot sandwich, served with mashed potatoes and covered with gravy. Choice of roast beef, pork, meatloaf or turkey.
–
Noodles over Mashed Potatoes
Noodles cooked in chicken broth, served over our own real mashed potatoes.
–
Vegetable Plate
Any three side dishes and a tossed salad. No substitutions, please.
–
Chicken Stir Fry
Charbroiled chicken with sautéed vegetables – onions, carrots, mushrooms, broccoli and green peppers – served over rice. Choice of teriyaki glaze, ranch dressing or honey mustard sauce.
Sandwiches
Served on homemade grilled buns. Includes a side of French fries or cup of soup. Add slice of American, Swiss, Pepper Jack or Cheddar cheese. Add Salad Bar to any Sandwich Platter.
Hamburger
–
Dutchman Burger
5oz chopped sirloin, topped with Swiss cheese
–
Prime Rib
Shaved prime rib topped with sautéed mushrooms and melted Swiss cheese on a homemade sub bun. Served with a side of au jus.
–
Charbroiled Chicken Breast
Boneless, marinated and charbroiled.
–
Buffalo Chicken Breast
Crispy fried or boneless, skinless chicken breast, smothered in Buffalo sauce.
–
Smoked Sausage
–
Roast Turkey or Roast Pork
–
Roast Beef or BBQ Beef
–
Reuben
Corned beef, sauerkraut and Swiss cheese on rye, topped with Thousand Island dressing
–
Rachel
Turkey, sauerkraut and Swiss cheese on rye, topped with Thousand Island dressing
–
Fish
Deep-fried cod with light breading
–
Tilapia
Broiled in our own seasoning
–
Garden Burger
A flame-grilled, all vegetable patty bursting with bold seasoning
–
Grilled Cheese
FAMILY-STYLE DINNERS
Pass the potatoes! Enjoy Amish-style foods served around the table the old-fashioned way. Includes salad bar, real mashed potatoes, dressing, gravy, corn or green beans, dinner rolls, beverage and slice of pie or ice cream. We ask that all guests at the table order family style. Eat all you want here, but no doggie bags for leftovers. Gratuity not included.
SIDE DISHES
À la Carte
Homemade Noodles
Real Mashed Potatoes and Gravy
Chicken or beef gravy
Homemade Dressing & Gravy (Stuffing)
Hash Browns
French Fries
Amish Potato Cakes
Baked Potato
Baked Sweet Potato
Potato Wedges
Sweet Potato Fries
Chicken Rice Pilaf
Creamed Corn
Green Beans
Grilled Vegetables
Stewed Tomatoes
Steamed Mixed Vegetables with cheese sauce
Cole Slaw
Jello
Applesauce
Cottage Cheese
Tossed Salad
Fresh Fruit
BEVERAGES
Soft Drinks
Pepsi
Caffeine-free Diet Pepsi
Mountain Dew
Diet Mountain Dew
Sierra Mist
Root Beer
Dr. Pepper
Brisk Raspberry Tea
Pink Lemonade
(free refills)
–
Freshly Brewed Iced Tea
Sweet, Unsweet (free refills)
–
Flavored Iced Tea
Unsweetened Raspberry or Peach (free refills)
–
Juices
Orange, Apple, Tomato,
Grapefruit, Grape, Cranberry
Milk
White, Chocolate, Buttermilk
–
Fresh Ground Coffee
Regular, Decaffeinated (free refills)
–
Hot Tea
–
Hot Chocolate
–
Cappuccino
–
Bottled Water
Homemade Pies
Fruit Pie: Apple, Dutch Apple, Cherry, Peach, Blueberry
Cream Pie: Banana, Butterscotch, Chocolate, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Coconut, Peanut Butter, Red Raspberry
Other Favorites: Raisin, Custard, Lemon Meringue, Sugar Cream
Premium Pie: Black Raspberry Cream, German Chocolate, Pecan, Black Raspberry, Blackberry
No Sugar Added: Apple, Cherry, Coconut Cream, Banana Cream
Ask about our fresh Seasonal Pies flavors!
Ice Cream
Homemade Ice Cream
Vanilla or Chocolate
–
Sundae
Strawberry, Chocolate, Hot Fudge, Caramel
–
Milkshake
Strawberry, Chocolate, Vanilla
–
Banana Split
-
Hot Fudge Brownie Sundae
Dutchman Favorites
Bread Pudding
Topped with vanilla sauce
–
Date Nut Pudding
–
Angel Food Cake
–
Chocolate Chip Cookie
–
Cookie ala Mode
Chocolate Chip Cookie served with ice cream and chocolate syrup
Espresso, Tea and Smoothies
–
–
Dinners
Includes one of the choices below plus two side dishes and ice cream. Ages 10 and under.
Chicken
Choose two chicken fingers or two drumsticks
–
*Charbroiled Chicken Breast
–
Roast Turkey
–
*Fish
–
Roast Beef
–
Ham
* Denotes healthier menu options for kids
Sandwiches
includes one side dish and ice cream
Grilled Cheese
–
Cheeseburger
–
Hamburger
–
Fish
–
Hot Dog
–
Corn Dog
Made with Chicken Franks
–
PB & Jelly
Strawberry or Grape Jelly
Side Dishes
Real Mashed Potatoes
French Fries
Homemade Noodles
*Green Beans
Homemade Dressing
Macaroni & Cheese
Creamed Corn
Applesauce
Coleslaw
*Tossed Salad
*Fresh Fruit
Jello
Buffet, Salad Bar
*Salad Bar
–
Buffet & *Salad Bar
Beverages
Small Beverage
Pepsi
Diet Pepsi
Mountain Dew
Diet Mountain Dew
Sierra Mist
Dr. Pepper
Root Beer
Pink Lemonade
White Milk
Chocolate Milk
Hot Chocolate
BREAKFAST
Available 6am to 11am.
One Egg & Toast
Served with 2 pieces bacon or 1 sausage patty
–
One Pancake
Served with 2 pieces bacon or 1 sausage patty
–
One Egg & Pancake
–
One Slice French Toast
Served with 2 pieces bacon or 1 sausage patty
Desserts
Homemade Ice Cream
–
Cookie
–
“Frost-your-own” Cookie
–
Milkshake
–
Sundae
Hot Fudge, Strawberry,Caramel, Chocolate
Healthy Options are included on our dinner menu.
DINNERs
Include optional Dinner role and two sides
Dinner Roll
120 calories, 2g fat, 320mg sodium, 23g carbs
–
Charbroiled Chicken Breast
5oz boneless serving, unmarinated and charbroiled
180 calories, 2.5g fat, 85mg sodium, 0g carbs
–
Pork Chop
4oz bone-in pork chop, charbroiled
250 calories, 12g fat, 75mg sodium, 0g carbs
–
Tilapia
6-8oz serving, broiled with lemon pepper seasoning
70 calories, 0.5g fat, 60mg sodium, less than 1g carbs
–
Salmon
6-8oz serving, broiled tender
160 calories, 7g fat, 125mg sodium, 0g carbs
–
Cod
7-95oz serving, broiled with lemon pepper seasoning
100 calories, 1g fat, 120mg sodium, 1g carbs
Sides
Baked Potato
260 calories, 5g fat, 15mg sodium, 49g carbs
–
Sweet Potato
100 calories, 0g fat, 40mg sodium, 24g carbs
–
Garden Blend Rice
140 calories., 0.5g fat, 470mg sodium, 29g carbs
–
Green Beans
15 calories, 0g fat, 290mg sodium, 4g carbs
–
Fresh Fruit Cup
100 calories, 0g fat, 10mg sodium, 26g carbs
–
Tossed Salad
100 calories, 3g fat, 210mg sodium, 16g carbs
–
Grilled Vegetables
30 calories, 0g fat, 30mg sodium, 6g carbs
Additional Meals
Chicken Stir Fry
5oz chicken breast with mushrooms, broccoli, cauliflower, carrots, snow peas, green peppers and onions, served over rice.
280 calories, 3g fat, 170mg sodium, 20g carbs
–
Grilled Chicken Salad
Fresh, crisp salad with garden vegetables and topped with Colby cheese and 5oz unmarinated grilled chicken breast
230 calories, 3g fat, 115mg sodium, 15g carbs
–
Strawberry Poppyseed Salad
Spinach and romaine lettuce, honey-roasted pecans, fresh strawberries, Feta cheese (optional), and 5oz unmarinated, grilled chicken breast. Served with poppyseed dressing.
260 calories, 24g fat, 150mg sodium, 10g carbs
with Feta, add 70 calories, 5g fat, 290mg sodium, 2g carbs
Healthy Option Salad Dressings
Ranch (30g) – 100 calories, 10g fat, 100mg sodium, 1g carbs
French (30g) – 90 calories, 6g fat, 210mg sodium, 9g carbs
Sweet & Sour (30g) – 190 calories, 15g fat, 30mg sodium, 13g carbs
Vinegar & Oil (30g) – 140 calories, 15g fat, 0mg sodium, 0g carbs
Desserts
No Sugar Added Apple Pie
80 calories, 2g fat, 130mg sodium, 14g carbs
–
No Sugar Added Cherry Pie
70 calories, .5g fat, 90mg sodium, 17g carbs
–
Angel Food Cake
60 calories, 0g fat, 140mg sodium, 12g carbs
–
Vanilla Yogurt
100 calories, 2.5g fat, 55mg sodium, 16g carbs
Peanut oil is not used in our restaurants.
Always note when pecans or nuts are used in our products!
Wheat flour is used in our kitchen.
–
Foods Containing MSG
Chicken Pot Pie
Creamed Chicken
Wedding Steak
Smoked Sausage
Sausage Patties
Sausage Links
Poor Man’s Steak
Ranch Dressing
Lemon Pepper (on Fish)
Steak Sandwich
Swiss Steak
Gluten-Free Foods
Char-broiled Chicken Breast
Roast Turkey
Roast Pork
Chopped Sirloin
Roast Beef
Liver & Onions
Grilled Ham
Country Cured Ham
Pork Chops
Tilapia
Salmon
Mashed Potatoes (no gravy)
Baked Potato
Hash Browns or Home Fries
Baked Sweet Potato
Rice Pilaf
Steamed Vegetables (no cheese sauce)
Green Beans
Tossed Salad
Cottage Cheese
Applesauce
Jello
Glazed Fruit
Homemade Ice Cream
Foods Containing Milk
Dressing or Stuffing
Mashed Potatoes
Pancakes
Sausage Gravy
French Toast
Cheese Sauce
Macaroni & Cheese
Lasagna (in cheese)
Homemade Ice Cream
Bread Pudding
Broccoli Cheese Soup
Tomato Basil Soup
Cheesy Vegetable Soup
Tomato Gravy
Noodles
Chicken & Noodles
Chicken Gravy
Chicken Pot Pie
Foods Containing Eggs
Amish Peanut Butter Spread
Chicken Gravy
Dressing or Stuffing
Noodles
Pancakes
French Toast
Potato Cakes
Meatloaf
Homemade Ice Cream
Bread Pudding
Chicken Pot Pie
Creamed Chicken
Poor Man’s Steak
Chicken Noodle Casserole
Potato Salad
Macaroni Salad
Ham Loaf
Vegan Menu
Green Beans
No butter added
Steamed Vegetables
Baked Potato
Baked Sweet Potato
Rice
French Fries*
Sweet Potato Fries*
Onion Rings*
*Made with trans fat free Canola Oil
Veggie Burger
No bun
Garden Salad
With no cheese or croutons
Three-Bean Salad**
**Made with trans fat free Soy Oil
Cucumber Slaw
Pasta Salad
Applesauce
Glazed Fruit
Fruit Slush
Fresh Fruit
BREAKFAST
Breakfast Burrito
served with potato wedges
–
Breakfast Buffet
7:30am to 11am
LUNCH
Lunch Buffet
11:30am to 4pm
SOUP OF THE DAY
Potato
LUNCH AND DINNER
Featured Side Dish
Succotash
–
Homemade Ham Loaf
With your choice of 2 side dishes.
-
Featured Soup - Stuffed Pepper
Dinner Buffet - Featuring Spaghetti with a Homemade Spicy Meat Sauce
4pm to 8pm
BREAKFAST
Malted Belgian Waffle
Add whipped cream or fruit!
–
Breakfast Buffet
7:30am to 11am
LUNCH
Lunch Buffet
11:30am to 4pm
SOUP OF THE DAY
Tomato
Oct-May
LUNCH AND DINNER
Featured Side Dish- Fresh Green Beans with Onions & Garlic
–
Creamed Chicken over Biscuits & Mashed Potatoes
Add salad bar for an additional charge.
–
Pan-Fried Chicken
Choose your choice of 2 side dishes
Dinner Buffet
4pm to 8pm
Featuring Fresh Grilled Green Beans with Onions and Garlic
Sauerkraut & Smoked Sausage
Featured Soup - Stuffed Pepper
BREAKFAST
Cinnamon Roll French Toast
–
Breakfast Buffet
7:30am to 11am
LUNCH
Lunch Buffet
11:30am to 4pm
SOUP OF THE DAY
Ham and Bean
with cornbread
LUNCH AND DINNER
Chicken Salad Croissant
With your choice of one side dish
–
Beef Short Ribs
Mashed potatoes, side dish
–
Dinner Buffet
4pm to 8pm
Featuring Glazed Baby Carrots
Featured Soup - Stuffed Pepper
BREAKFAST
Ham & Spinach Quiche
–
Breakfast Buffet
7:30am to 11am
LUNCH
Lunch Buffet
11:30am to 4pm
SOUP OF THE DAY
Broccoli Cheese
-
Featured Side Dish
Steamed Cabbage
-
Featured Soup
Stuffed Pepper
LUNCH AND DINNER
BBQ Ribs
With your choice of 1 side dish
–
Beef & Noodles & Mashed Potatoes
Add our Salad Bar for an additional charge
–
Dinner Buffet
4pm to 8pm
Featuring Sweet & Sour Noodles with Chicken
Steamed Cabbage
BREAKFAST
Breakfast Casserole
–
Breakfast Buffet
7am to 11am
LUNCH
Lunch Buffet - Featuring Cabbage Rolls
11:30am to 4pm
SOUP OF THE DAY
Clam Chowder
LUNCH AND DINNER
Featured Side Dish
Macaroni & Cheese
-
Featured Soup
Stuffed Pepper
–
Baked Vegetable Lasagna
With Salad Bar
–
All-You-Can-Eat Fried Pollock
With any 2 side dishes
–
Dinner Buffet - Featuring Cod
4pm to 8pm
BREAKFAST
Baked Oatmeal
Served with milk and brown sugar
-
Breakfast Buffet
7am to 11am
LUNCH
Dinner Buffet
11:30am to 9pm
SOUP OF THE DAY
Chicken Tortilla
LUNCH AND DINNER
Creamed Chicken and Noodles
Over mashed potatoes - Served 11am - 4pm
–
Featured on the Hot Buffet
Country Ribs - Served 11am - 3pm
Dinner Buffet
11:30am to 9pm
Broasted Chicken
6 pieces, 11.59
9 pieces, 16.99
12 pieces, 21.79
15 pieces, 26.19
18 pieces, 30.49
21 pieces, 34.29
42 pieces, 65.39
50 pieces, 74.79
100 pieces, 139.99
All white meat, add 40%
Roast Beef
11.99/lb
Baked Ham
9.99/lb
Roast Pork
9.99/lb
Roast Turkey (Mix)
9.99/lb
Roast Turkey (White Meat Only)
10.99/lb
Mashed Potatoes, Homemade Dressing, Green Beans, Noodles, Creamed Corn
Pint, 4.29
Quart, 6.99
Gallon, 23.99
Potato Salad, 3 Bean Salad, Macaroni Salad, Cole Slaw, Broccoli and Cauliflower Salad, Pasta Salad
Pint, 4.29
Quart, 6.99
Gallon, 23.99
Crowd-pleasing carry-out meal packages for the entire family!
Meat Choices
Ham, beef, turkey or chicken
Side Dishes
Mashed potatoes, dressing, noodles, green beans, creamed corn, macaroni salad, potato salad, broccoli-cauliflower salad
Gravy
Chicken or beef
Pies
Assorted, see our Dessert Menu
Serves Four —
Includes one meat selection, one side dish, and dinner rolls
$19.99
A meal with two side dishes - $24.99
Long before our 5am opening, our bakers are up making, baking and glazing 10 kinds of breads and rolls, 20 varieties of fruit, cream and crumb pies, dozens of apple fritters, and an array of other from-scratch, hand-fluted goodies.
Christmas Cookie Trays
Trays include Christmas cut-outs, peanut butter blossoms, Russian tea balls, monster cookies and date pinwheels.
Large Tray – $25.99
3 dozen cookies
Extra Large Tray – $36.99
4½ dozen cookies
If you prefer all iced cut-outs instead of the assortment, please add 25% to the prices above.
Pastries
Apple Fritter
Cinnamon Roll
Long John
Donut twists
Crullers
Jelly-filled donuts
Pecan Roll
Glazed Donuts
–
Cake-style Donuts
Chocolate, Vanilla, Pumpkin, Blueberry
Muffins
Cranberry
Lemon Poppyseed
Blueberry
Pumpkin
Bran
Chocolate
Coffee Cake
Pantry Favorites
Noodles
Amish Peanut Butter Spread
Apple Butter
Jams, Jellies & Preserves
Granola
Croutons
Fudge
Mush
Bread Pudding
Cheese Spread
Cold Cut Meats and Cheeses
Pies
Fruit Pie
Black Raspberry
Blackberry
Blueberry
Cherry*
Peach
Apple*
Dutch Apple
Raisin
–
Specialty Pie
Sugar Cream
Custard
Lemon Meringue
Pecan
German Chocolate
–
Cream Pie
Coconut Cream*
Peanut Butter Cream
Chocolate Cream
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream
Banana Cream*
Butterscotch Cream
Red Raspberry Cream
Black Raspberry Cream
–
Seasonal Pie
Fresh Summer Peach
Fresh Strawberry
Rhubarb
Grape
Mincemeat
Pumpkin*
Strawberry Banana
Strawberry Rhubarb
* Also available with no added sugar
–
Whoopie Pies
Chocolate
Pumpkin
Breads
Whole Wheat**
White**
Cinnamon
Raisin
Apple Butter
Pumpernickel
Muesli
Rye
Sourdough
Banana
Pumpkin
English Muffin
Garlic Pull-a-Part
Focaccia
** Loaves, rolls, & sandwich buns
Cakes
Angel Food
Vanilla
Chocolate
Carrot
German Chocolate
Pumpkin Roll
Chocolate Roll
Chocolate Honey Cream
Apple Honey Cream
Cherry Honey Cream
Peach Honey Cream
Pecan Honey Cream
–
Special Order
Birthday Cakes
Cookies
Buttermilk
Chocolate Chip
Coconut
Honey Nut Raisin
Monster
Peanut Butter
Chocolate Crinkle
Raisin Oatmeal
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Snicker Doodle
Sugar
Oatmeal
No-Bake cookies
Raisin-filled
Raspberry Shortbread
Pumpkin
–
Cookie Dough
–
Cookie Bars
Lemon Bars
Heavenly Bars
Brownies
Mint Brownies
Double deck Brownies
–
Carry-Out
The Bakery offers carry-out service for all items on the Der Dutchman breakfast, lunch, and dinner menu.
Call ahead. 614-873-3414
Der Dutchman baked goods are available or served at these establishments in the Columbus area. Find our partners
The Andersons Store
7000 Bent Tree Blvd
Columbus, Ohio
937-642-0363 | Website
Amish Heritage Country Market
728 North Main St
Marysville, Ohio
614-766-9500 | Website
The Best Breakfast and Sandwiches
5916 Westerville Rd
Westerville, Ohio
614-776-5788
Bridgewater Banquet and Conference Center
10651 Sawmill Pkwy
Powell, Ohio
614-734-9800 | Website
Caffe Tomaso
5455 Rings Ave
Dublin, Ohio
614-761-8425
CJ’s Market
5 S Mill St
Milford Center, Ohio
937-349-4015
Columbus Convention Center
400 N High St.
Columbus, Ohio
614-827-2500 | Website
Corner Carry Out
537 S Maple St
Marysville, Ohio
937-642-2933
Freeman’s Market
6146 Lewis Center Rd
Galena, Ohio
740-548-1149
First Community Village
1800 Riverside Dr
Columbus, Ohio
614-324-4455 | Website
Grand Day Cafe
1284 West 5th Ave
Columbus, Ohio
614-481-3363
Hickory House
550 Officenter Pl
Gahanna, Ohio
614-428-7427
7051 E Main St
Reynoldsburg, Ohio
614-861-5962 | Website
Jimmy V's Grill and Pub
1 South State St
Westerville, Ohio
614-865-9090 | Website
The Hills Market
7860 Olentangy River Rd
Columbus, Ohio
614-846-3220
95 North Grant
Columbus, Ohio
614-985-1440 | Website
Huffman’s Market
2140 Tremont Center
Columbus, Ohio
614-486-5336 | Website
Kuhlwein’s Farm Market
1859 Walker Rd
Hilliard, Ohio
614-876-2833
Larry B’s Meat & Cheese
203 West Main St
West Jefferson, Ohio
614-879-6000
Lily’s Kitchen Table
4008 Broadway
Grove City, Ohio
614-801-0771 | Website
Lucky’s Market
2768 North High St
Columbus, Ohio
614-447-0258
Madriver Farm Market
7538 US Highway 68 North
West Liberty, Ohio
937-465-2030
Marathon
4400 Roberts Rd
Columbus, Ohio
614-771-0204
Marathon
215 West Bridge St
Dublin, Ohio
614-889-1860
Marathon
7810 Olentangy River Rd
Worthington, Ohio
614-846-8443
McAuliffe’s
1299 West 5th St
Marysville, Ohio
937-642-2891
Mid-way Market (Shell)
8208 Marysville Rd
Ostrander, Ohio
740-666-4935
Miller’s Country Gardens
2488 West State Rt 37
Delaware, Ohio
740-363-5021 | Website
Mosier’s IGA
21701 Main St
Raymond, Ohio
937-246-3772
New Era Market
7775 Dublin Rd
Powell, Ohio
740-881-4142
New Grounds Coffee House
6318 Scioto Darby Rd
Hilliard, Ohio
614-876-9246
Phillip’s Coney Island
450 West Broad St
Columbus, Ohio
614-221-8288
Pilot
1365 Northeast State Route 42
London, Ohio
740-879-4128
Pilot
3600 Interchange Rd
Columbus, Ohio
614-308-9195
The Pit Stop
23255 State Route 4
Marysville, Ohio
937-578-0023
Putt-N-Play
4021 Thislewood Dr
Grove City, Ohio
614-594-0077
Red Door Tavern
1736 West 5th Ave
Columbus, Ohio
614-488-5433 | Website
Rhodes Tower Cafe
30 East Broad St
Columbus, Ohio
614-752-8381
Rife Tower Cafe
77 South High St
Columbus, Ohio
614-460-7211
Schuman’s Meats
1440 Harrisburg Pike
Columbus, Ohio
614-274-2161 | Website
Scioto Downs
6000 S High St
Columbus, Ohio
614-295-4700
Shell
3088 Broadway
Grove City, Ohio
614-871-5070
South of Lane
1987 Guilford Rd
Upper Arlington, Ohio
614-586-2233
Sunoco
648 Grandview Ave
Columbus, Ohio
614-488-2464
Uptown Deli and Brew
41 North State St
Westerville, Ohio
614-891-2337 | Website
Village Mart Marathon
10152 State Route 42
Marysville, Ohio
614-873-4855
Weiland’s Market
3600 Indianola Ave
Columbus, Ohio
614-267- 9878 | Website
Winans Fine Chocolates and Coffee
52 South High St
Dublin, Ohio
614-766-7061 | Website
3425 Morse Crossing
Columbus, Ohio
Yutzy’s Cheese House
1522 East State Route 36
Urbana, Ohio
937-653-4282 | Website
From corporate meetings to weddings to community and family groups, we make every event a special occasion. Close to central Ohio and just outside Columbus, groups and guests appreciate gathering in a delightfully furnished and spacious facility with rural charm and gracious service.
Our excellent facilities and experienced staff members ensure that your events will be easy to plan, productive and memorable.
For more information, please call 614-873-3414.
Our reasonable prices and long list of amenities make this an easy way to experience the simple pleasures of small-town Plain City.
For more information, please call 614-873-3414.
Thanks to our family-friendly venue and charming surroundings, you can have the romantic country wedding reception of your dreams.
For more information, please call 614-873-3414.
Plan your next event at a place that shares your values on family, faith and fellowship. Der Dutchman Restaurant extends a warm welcome to everyone from community and non-profit organizations to church groups and families.
For more than 20 years, the quality and goodness known to Central Ohio as Der Dutchman Restaurant has attracted patrons from far and wide. But you don’t have to travel to Plain City to experience the simple pleasures of our authentic Amish Kitchen Cooking. We also offer full-service catering that delivers our delicious, made-from-scratch food directly to your business event, wedding reception, or special occasion, along with exceptional value and attentive service.
Crowd-pleasing flavors
What makes the Der Dutchman catering experience so special? For starters, you can taste the tradition. The cooks in our kitchen use time-honored methods to create exactly the kind of simple, flavorful foods that lend themselves to feeding and satisfying a crowd.
Specially seasoned, all-natural meats roasted, broasted, and slow-cooked to tender perfection and served piping hot. Plates piled high with savory, made-from-scratch side dishes, like classic bread stuffing, real mashed potatoes and gravy, or homemade egg noodles. Slow-simmered soups, garden-fresh salads, and sandwiches made with just-baked breads and rolls. And there’s always a selection of our famous homemade pies and pastries, for a sweet finish from the Der Dutchman Bakery.
Options for every occasion
Our catering menu offers abundant options for bringing the delicious Der Dutchman experience to events of all types and sizes, day or night. The selection ranges from tasty appetizer platters and cheese trays to hearty boxed lunches, family-style meals, and, of course, our country buffets for breakfast, lunch, or dinner.
Whatever the event, our trained servers are there to set up the food table, assist during the meal, and take care of the details so the hosts can relax and enjoy the event knowing every guest is well taken care of.
Der Dutchman Restaurant & Bakery
Monday–Thursday: 6am–8pm
Friday and Saturday: 6am–9pm
Sunday: Closed
Carlisle Gifts
Monday–Thursday: 8am–8pm
Friday and Saturday: 8am–9pm
Sunday: Closed
NEW YEAR'S DAY
Closed
Good Friday - April 19
6am–9pm
MEMORIAL DAY - May 27
6am–7pm
JULY 4
6am–7pm
Labor DAY - September 2
6am–7pm
thanksgiving eve
6am–8pm
THANKSGIVING DAY
Closed
CHRISTMAS EVE
6am to 2pm
CHRISTMAS DAY 2019
Closed
new year's eve 2019
6am to 2pm
new year's day 2020
Closed