Sarasota, Florida
Stop by any time of day for a lovely, scratch-made breakfast, lunch or dinner, including mouth-watering favorites like slow-roasted turkey, specialties like Tilapia and Shrimp, and Der Dutchman’s legendary pies and desserts.
Country Breakfast Buffet
Served 7:00–11:00am Monday through Friday; 7:00–11:30am on Saturday
Scrambled eggs, bacon, smoked sausage, fried corn mush, sausage gravy, biscuits, hash browns, cheesy potatoes, pancakes, french toast, oatmeal, grits, fresh pastries, fresh fruit, yogurt, fruit slush
Hot off the Grill
Emanuel’s Favorite
Buttermilk biscuit with sausage gravy, two eggs, hash browns, choice of meat (ham, bacon or sausage) and homemade toast.
–
Egg & Cheese Sandwich
On homemade toast or English muffin with medley of fruit
–
Croissant Sandwich
Egg, cheese and your choice of ham, bacon or sausage on croissant with medley of fruit
3-Egg Omelettes
Served with homemade toast and hash browns or grits. Substitute cholesterol-free egg-lites for .40
Cheese Omelette
–
Ham & Cheese Omelette
–
Vegetarian Omelette
Tomatoes, mushrooms, onions and green peppers
–
Spinach Omelette
Spinach, mushrooms and tomatoes
–
Western Omelette
Ham, green peppers, onions and cheese
–
Extra cheese, additional .30
Light Syrup available
Each individual item will be charged à la carte.
–
Breakfast Burrito
Served with a medley of fruit and choice of ham, bacon or sausage
Side Orders
Egg
–
Ham, Bacon, or Sausage
–
Turkey Sausage
–
Sausage or Tomato Gravy
–
Grits
–
Hash Browns
PANCAKES & WAFFLES
Buttermilk Pancakes
–
Blueberry or Chocolate Chip Pancakes
–
Belgian Waffle
Fresh fruit in season, ask server
Dutchman FAVORITES
Nappanee Starter
Two eggs and homemade toast
–
Sarasota Sunrise
Two eggs, homemade toast and your choice of hash browns or grits
–
Pinecraft Barn Raiser
Two eggs, your choice of ham, bacon or sausage, hash browns and homemade toast
–
Dutch Scramble
Scrambled eggs served with a combination of ham and hash browns, topped with melted cheese and served with homemade toast
–
Walnut Creek Breakfast
Two eggs, your choice of ham, bacon or sausage and homemade toast
–
Lancaster Hearty Starter
Tender 8 oz. chopped sirloin with two eggs, hash browns or grits and homemade toast
–
Eggs Benedict
Served with hash browns or grits
–
Healthy Start
Country style turkey sausage, Egg Beaters, fresh fruit cup, and toast
French Toast
Made with thick slices of our homemade bread and served with warm syrup and sprinkled with powered sugar
–
Cinnamon French Toast or Apple Cinnamon French Toast
–
Cornmeal Mush
Crispy, golden slices of fried cornmeal mush served with warm syrup
–
Biscuits & Gravy
Creamy, homemade sausage gravy ladled over fresh-baked biscuits
Fruit & Cereal
Homemade Granola
–
Cold Cereal
–
Hot Oatmeal
–
Baked Oatmeal
Served with milk and brown sugar
–
Fresh Fruit
–
Fresh Fruit Parfait
Fresh fruit with choice of vanilla or strawberry yogurt and homemade granola. Served with your choice of toast, English muffin, bagel or homemade muffin
BREADS & PASTRIES
Homemade Toast
White, Wheat, Rye, Sourdough, Raisin, Multi-Grain or Cinnamon
–
Buttermilk Biscuits
Two biscuits served with jelly
DOUGHNUTS
Cake, Sugared or Glazed
–
Apple fritters, Cinnamon buns, Jelly-filled, Cream sticks or Twists
–
Muffins
Bran, Banana, Blueberry, Pumpkin, Chocolate, Cranberry or Lemon poppyseed
–
Cinnamon Sweet Roll
–
Cinnamon Coffee Cake
–
Pecan Sticky Buns
–
Although not made in our bakery, we also offer
English Muffin
–
Bagels
Plain, Raisin or Blueberry with cream cheese
CHILDREN'S BREAKFAST
10 years old and under
Mornin’ Starter
One egg served with bacon or sausage and homemade toast
–
Pancakes
Five mini pancakes served with bacon or sausage; with chocolate chips, add .40
–
Fruit -N- Yogurt
Fresh fruit with a cup of low-fat yogurt
–
Cereal -N- Yogurt
Cereal (choose Fruit Loops or Cheerios) with a cup of low-fat yogurt
Beverages
Coffee
Regular or Decaf, Care Cup International®
–
Hot Tea
Regular, Decaffeinated or Herbal
–
Hot Chocolate
–
Cappuccino
–
Milk
White or Chocolate
–
Juice
Apple, Grape, V8 or Cranberry
–
Fresh Juice
Fresh, locally-squeezed juices: Orange, Strawberry-Orange or Grapefruit
–
Iced Tea
Sweetened, Unsweetened, Raspberry or Mint
–
Lemonade
–
Soda
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Sierra Mist, Orange Crush, Root Beer, Dr. Pepper
All-You-Can-Eat Salad Bar
Everyone enjoys a trip to our beautiful Salad Bar. As bountiful as a garden and as colorful as a quilt, the array includes fresh vegetables, prepared salads, and regional specialties that are constantly refilled and refreshed. We take pride in supporting our local growers and serve their fresh produce on our salad bar when in season.
Soups and Salads
Homemade Soup
Our soups are made daily. Ask your server for the soup of the day
Chili, Vegetable Beef, Chicken Noodle
–
Cup of Soup & Salad Bar
–
Tossed Salad
–
Chef Salad
Fresh, crisp salad tossed with garden vegetables, cheese and your choice of chicken, turkey, roast beef or ham
–
Taco Salad
Crisp salad in a taco shell bowl, topped with fresh tomatoes, chili, cheese blend, salsa and sour cream
–
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, Parmesan cheese and Caesar dressing
–
Southwestern Salad
Romaine and iceberg lettuce, avocado, black beans, pico de gallo, tortilla strips, fajita grilled chicken strips, Mexican cheese blend. Served with chipotle ranch dressing.
–
Strawberry Poppy Seed Salad
Spinach and Romaine lettuce, strawberries, honey roasted pecans, feta cheese, grilled chicken breast. Served with poppy seed dressing
–
Salad Dressings:
Sweet & Sour, Thousand Island, Bleu Cheese, French, Honey Mustard, Ranch, Lite Italian, Poppyseed, Fat-Free Ranch, Vinegar & Oil
Lighter Appetite
Half-Sandwich and Cup of Soup
Choice of cold turkey, ham, chicken salad or tuna salad sandwich on your choice of bread and cup of soup
–
Noodles Over Mashed Potatoes
Homemade noodles over our own real mashed potatoes
–
One-Piece Broasted Chicken
Choose 1 Leg or 1 Thigh; served with your choice of two side dishes
–
Creamed Chicken
Served with vegetables over mashed potatoes and biscuits
–
Chicken Strips
Breaded chicken strips served with your choice of one side dish
–
Vegetable Plate
Three hot vegetable side dishes with your choice of coleslaw or tossed salad
–
Tuna or Chicken Salad Plate
Served with tomato wedges
–
Low-Cal Plate
Cottage cheese, tomato slices and fruit. Add a 6 oz. charbroiled chicken breast or 100% Angus beef chopped sirloin
–
Tilapia
5 oz. filet, hand-breaded and deep fried, blackened or broiled and brushed with a Bearnaise sauce with your choice of one side
–
Add Salad Bar to any of the meals above, additional 3.49
Dinner Dishes
Dinners include homemade dinner rolls and your choice of any two side dishes. Substitute Salad Bar as a side dish.
Chicken
Broasted Chicken
Broasted chicken is marinated, breaded and broasted under pressure for a crispy outside and juicy inside
–
Charbroiled Chicken Breast
6 oz. boneless, marinated and charbroiled or blackened
–
“Better Yet” Chicken Breast
6 oz. boneless, marinated and charbroiled chicken breast smothered with mushrooms, bacon and melted cheese
–
Chicken Nuggets
Delicious all white meat with crispy breading
Turkey
Roast Turkey
Tender and juicy old-fashioned, slow-roasted turkey
Beef
Old-Fashioned Roast Beef
Amish style chuck roast baked 8 hours in its natural juices
–
Chopped Sirloin
8 oz. charbroiled or blackened 100% Angus beef chopped sirloin.
–
Meatloaf
A hearty portion of homemade Amish-style meatloaf served with our special sauce
–
Liver & Onions
Grilled liver topped with sautéed onions
Pork
Boneless Pork Loin
Marinated, season and chargrilled
–
Grilled Ham
Delicious boneless, sugar-cured ham
Seafood
Tilapia
8–10 oz. filet, hand-breaded and deep fried, blackened or broiled and brushed with a Bearnaise sauce
–
Shrimp
Seven butterfly shrimp lightly breaded and deep fried to perfection
–
Shrimp Skewers
Ten shrimp grilled or blackened
–
Haddock
8 oz. batter-dipped and deep fried Atlantic haddock
–
Cod Filet
8 oz. mild North Atlantic cod deep fried with crispy breading
–
Seafood Platter
Breaded shrimp, battered cod, hush puppies, french fries and coleslaw
Sandwiches
All of our sandwiches are served with made-from-scratch breads and buns, fresh from our bakery. Served with your choice of cup of soup or french fries. With Salad Bar, add 3.89
Manhattans
Hot sandwich served with mashed potatoes and covered with gravy. Your choice of old-fashioned roast beef, turkey, or meatloaf.
–
100% Angus Burger
Charbroiled 100% Angus beef
–
Turkey, Roast Beef or Pork
Served hot or cold on your choice of fresh baked bread
–
Chicken Filet
Chicken breast, breaded and deep fried
–
Boneless Chicken Breast
Marinated and charbroiled to perfection
–
Ham & Swiss
Served hot or cold on your choice of fresh baked bread
–
Grilled Cheese
Homemade bread with your choice of American, Swiss or Provolone cheese
–
Veggie Burger
Charbroiled all-vegetable patty
–
Cod
5 oz. filet lightly breaded and deep fried
–
Tilapia
6 oz. filet, hand-breaded and deep fried, blackened or broiled and brushed with a Bearnaise sauce
–
Tuna or Chicken Salad
Served with tomato and lettuce on your choice of homemade rye, wheat or white bread
–
All-Beef Chili Dog
All-beef hot dog smothered with chili, cheese and onions
Side Dishes
À la Carte
Amish Potato Cakes
Applesauce
Baked Beans
Baked Potato
Baked Sweet Potato
Coleslaw
Cottage Cheese
Creamed Corn
French Fries
Fruit Jell-O
Green Beans
Homemade Dressing (Stuffing)
Homemade Noodles
Real Mashed Potatoes with gravy
Rice Pilaf
Side Salad
Steamed Vegetables with
Cheese Sauce
Onion Rings
Sweet Potato Fries
Sweet Potato Soufflé
Barn-Raising Buffet
The tradition of an Amish barn-raising meal or a Mennonite church potluck is all about coming together, sharing abundance, choosing as you go and lots of variety! Here are our versions:
Lunch Buffet
The Lunch Buffet offers several selections of homemade soups, hot and cold sandwiches, our famous broasted chicken, real mashed potatoes, green beans, macaroni and cheese, salad bar and more.
–
Dinner Buffet
The Dinner Buffet features broasted chicken, juicy old-fashioned roast beef, ham or turkey, stuffing, real mashed potatoes, creamed corn, green beans, homemade noodles, salad bar and more.
Eat all you want, but no leftovers may be taken home.Salad Bar and Buffet sharers will be charged full price.
For a Change
Craving something a little different? Try these delicious combos.
Dutchman Burger
8 oz. charbroiled or blackened 100% Angus beef chopped sirloin. Topped with American or Swiss cheese and served with french fries or coleslaw
Western Burger
8 oz. charbroiled 100% Angus beef chopped sirloin. Topped with Swiss cheese, mushrooms, grilled onions and barbecue sauce and served with french fries or coleslaw
–
Dutchman Wrap
Iceberg lettuce, pico de gallo, shredded cheese, and choice of chicken or fish (grilled or blackened) wrapped in a fresh tortilla.
Served with french fries or coleslaw.
–
Stir Fry
Charbroiled chicken breast or shrimp with sautéed vegetables—onions, carrots, mushrooms, broccoli, and green peppers—in teriyaki glaze served over rice
Beverages
Soda
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Sierra Mist, Orange Crush, Root Beer, Dr. Pepper (free refills)
–
Cold Drinks
Sweet Iced Tea, Unsweetened Iced Tea, Raspberry Iced Tea, Garden Mint Iced Tea, Lemonade (free refills)
–
Juices
Apple, Grape, Cranberry
–
Fresh-Squeezed Orange or Grapefruit Juice
From local groves
–
Milk
White or Chocolate
–
Coffee
Regular or Decaf (free refills) Care Cup International® brand coffee
–
Hot Tea
Regular or Mint
–
Hot Chocolate
–
Cappuccino
–
Bottled Water
Slice of Pie
Fruit Pies: Apple, Cherry, Dutch Apple, Peach, Rhubarb Crumb, Strawberry Rhubarb, Blackberry, Blueberry
Available with No Sugar Added: Apple, Cherry
Cream Pies: Banana, Butterscotch, Chocolate, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Coconut, Peanut Butter
Other Favorites: Custard, Key Lime, Lemon Meringue, Pumpkin
Slice of Premium Pie
Pecan, Black Raspberry, Red Raspberry
–
Seasonal Fruit Pie
Fresh Strawberry or Peach
Cake of the Day
–
Bread Pudding
Served with caramel or vanilla sauce
–
Angel Food Cake
With ice cream or choice of topping, add 89¢
–
Soft Serve Ice Cream
Vanilla, Chocolate, Dutch Twist
Ice Cream Sundaes
Butterscotch, Chocolate, Strawberry
–
Hot Fudge Brownie Sundae
–
Milkshakes
Chocolate, Strawberry, Vanilla
–
Specialty Coffees are now served in our dining room.
Lunch & Dinner
include one side dish of your choice
Buffet
–
Chicken Dinner
Choice of Chicken Fingers, Chicken Nuggets or Two Drumsticks
–
*Grilled Chicken Breast
–
Fish
–
*Roast Turkey
–
Grilled Ham
–
6" Pizza
–
Macaroni & Cheese
–
Sandwiches
include french fries
Peanut Butter & Jelly
–
Hot Dog
–
Grilled Cheese
–
Fish
–
Hamburger
–
Cheeseburger
Side Dishes
À la Carte
Mashed Potatoes
Jell-O
French Fries
Applesauce
*Green Beans
*Strawberry Yogurt
Corn
*Fruit Cup
Noodles
*Sweet Potato Fries
Coleslaw
*Steamed Broccoli
Salad Bar
Beverages
Soda
(Free Refills) Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Sierra Mist, Root Beer, Dr. Pepper
–
Juices
Orange, Apple, Lemonade
–
Raspberry Iced Tea
–
Milk
White (2% or Low-Fat) or Chocolate
Desserts
Ice Cream
Chocolate, Vanilla or Twist
–
Sundae Delight
Chocolate, Strawberry or Butterscotch topped with whipped cream and a cherry
Lite Dinners
Includes one meat, two side dishes and optional dinner roll
Dinner Roll
120 calories | 2g fat | 320mg sodium | 23g carbs
–
Grilled Chicken Breast
6oz boneless serving, unmarinated
280 calories | 6g fat | 125mg sodium | 0g carbs
–
Grilled Pork Loin
5oz boneless serving, unseasoned
280 calories | 11g fat | 90mg sodium | 0g carbs
–
Grilled Salmon
6-8oz serving, unseasoned
280 calories | 13g fat | 170mg sodium | 0g carbs
Meals & Salads
Chicken Stir Fry
6oz chicken breast with mushrooms, broccoli, cauliflower, carrots, snow peas, green peppers, onions served over rice; with teriyaki glaze
740 calories | 9g fat | 1,550mg sodium | 100g carbs
–
Grilled Chicken Salad
6oz grilled chicken breast, crisp lettuce and garden vegetables
320 calories | 6g fat | 150mg sodium | 9g carbs
–
Strawberry Poppyseed Salad
Spinach and romaine lettuce, honey-roasted pecans, fresh strawberries, grilled chicken with poppyseed dressing
510 calories | 27g fat | 260mg sodium | 9g carbs
With Feta cheese, add:
70 calories | 5g fat | 290mg sodium | 2g carbs
–
Salad Dressings
Ranch, per serving (30g)
100 calories | 10g fat | 100mg sodium | 1g carbs
Sweet & Sour, per serving (30g)
190 calories | 15g fat | 30mg sodium | 13g carbs
French, per serving (30g)
90 calories | 6g fat | 210mg sodium | 9g carbs
Vinegar & Oil, per serving (30g)
140 calories | 15g fat | 0mg sodium | 0g carbs
Side Dishes
Baked Potato
230 calories | 0g fat | 25mg sodium | 53g carbs
–
Real Mashed Potatoes (no gravy)
100 calories | 2.5g fat | 270mg sodium | 18g carbs
–
Baked Sweet Potato
130 calories | 0g fat | 45mg sodium | 33g carbs
–
Garden Blend Rice
180 calories | 1g fat | 610mg sodium | 40g carbs
–
Green Beans
20 calories | 0g fat | 270mg sodium | 4g carbs
–
Fresh Fruit Cup
130 calories | 0g fat | 20mg sodium | 34g carbs
–
Side Salad
160 calories | 13g fat | 150mg sodium | 8g carbs
With Cheese, add 170 calories | 11g fat | 500mg sodium | 2g carbs
–
Grilled Vegetables
35 calories | 0g fat | 30mg sodium | 7g carbs
BREAKFAST
Healthy Start
480 calories | 12g fat | 1,120mg sodium | 50g carbs
Peanut oil is not used in our restaurants.
Always note when pecans or nuts are used in our products!
Wheat flour is used in our kitchen.
Foods Containing Milk
Dressing or Stuffing
Mashed Potatoes
Macaroni & Cheese
Homemade Ice Cream
Bread Pudding
Broccoli Cheese Soup
Tomato Gravy
Chicken Pot Pie
Greek Pasta Salad
Edamame Salad
Cauliflower Soup
Breakfast Items:
Waffles
Biscuits
Pancakes
Sausage Gravy
French Toast
Cheese Sauce
Foods Containing Eggs
Chicken Gravy
Dressing or Stuffing
Noodles
Pancakes
French Toast
Potato Cakes
Meatloaf
Homemade Ice Cream
Bread Pudding
Chicken Pot Pie
Creamed Chicken
Chicken Salad
Tuna Salad
Ham Salad
Coleslaw
Broccoli Salad
Potato Salad
Macaroni Salad
Ham Loaf
Foods Containing MSG
Croutons
Chicken Pot Pie
Cheesy Potatoes
Ranch Dressing
Scalloped Potatoes
Gluten-Free Foods
Charbroiled Chicken Breast
Roast Turkey
Roast Pork Loin
Chopped Sirloin
Roast Beef
Liver & Onions
Grilled Ham
Tilapia (no sauce)
Grouper
Salmon
Shrimp Skewers (grilled plain)
Mashed Potatoes
Baked Potatoes
Baked Sweet Potatoes
Steamed Vegetables
Green Beans
Applesauce
Cottage Cheese
Jello
Boneless Beef ribs
Ham & Bean Soup
Beef Veggie soup
Beet Eggs
Breakfast Items:
Eggs
Hashbrowns (from the grill)
Grits
Vegetable Omelet
Corn Flakes
Fruit Slush and Glazed Fruit
All Fresh Fruits and Veggies
Vegan Menu
Green Beans
No butter added
Steamed Vegetables
Baked Potato
Baked Sweet Potato
Rice
French Fries*
Sweet Potato Fries*
Onion Rings*
*Made with trans fat free Canola Oil
Veggie Burger
No bun
Garden Salad
With no cheese or croutons
Three-Bean Salad**
**Made with trans fat free Soy Oil
Cucumber Slaw
Pasta Salad
Applesauce
Glazed Fruit
Fruit Slush
Fresh Fruit
Coffee
Coffee of the Day
Served hot or cold
6:01am
Coffee of the day plus shot of espresso
Americano
Shot of espresso, hot water
Cappuccino
Shot of espresso, frothed milk
Deluxe Cappuccino
Cappuccino, flavor of choice
Latte
Shot of espresso, steamed milk
Served hot or cold
Deluxe Latte
Latte, flavor of choice
Served hot, cold or blended
Specialty Drinks
Served hot, cold, or blended and topped with whipped cream
Mocha Latte
Chocolate Coconut
White Chocolate Mocha
Salted Caramel Mocha
Chocolate, caramel, sea salt topping
Caramel Cream
Caramel, vanilla
Nutella Latte
Chocolate and hazelnut
Tea and Cocoa
Iced Tea
Sweet or unsweetened
Hot Tea
Chai
Black tea, spices, milk
Served hot or cold
Vanilla Chai Tea
Chai tea, vanilla
Served hot, cold, or blended
Deluxe Hot Cocoa
Chocolate, steamed milk
Steamer
Flavor of your choice, steamed milk
Syrups
Caramel, Coconut, Hazelnut, Vanilla, Cinnamon, Sugar-free Vanilla, Sugar-free Caramel
Sauces
Chocolate, White Chocolate, Caramel
Smoothies
100% crushed fruit, blended with ice
Flavors
Four Berry Blend
Strawberry
Pineapple
Paradise
Mango Tropics
Strawberry-Banana
Loyalty Card
10 stamps earn you a specialty or coffee drink of your choice! Ask for a Coffee Card in our Cafe.
Sports Team Special
For groups of 10 or more - one check is required. Please call ahead and mention this special. 941-955-8007
Includes–
All-you-can-eat Barn Raising Buffet
Dessert
Tax
Tip
Beverage is not included.
Family-Sized Portions
Build your own meal—Great for a sit-down meal with your family or parties.
Please call 941-955-8007 to place your order.
Broasted Chicken
8 pc, 15.99
16 pc, 29.99
24 pc, 41.99
32 pc, 55.99
40 pc, 66.99
-
Broasted Chicken Nuggets
12 pc, 7.99
20 pc, 11.99
30 pc, 16.99
50 pc, 26.99
Small Party Tray (approx. 40), 21.99
Medium Party Tray (approx. 70),37.99
Large Party Tray (approx. 150), 74.99
-
Bulk Meats
Old-Fashioned Roast Beef, 11.99/lb
Glazed Ham, 10.79/lb
Roast Turkey
Off-bone, Mixed or Dark, 10.79/lb
Off-bone, White, 11.59/lb
-
Side Dishes
Choose from Mashed Potatoes, Macaroni & Cheese, Noodles, Corn, Green Beans
Pint (serves 2–3), 3.99
Quart (serves 6–8), 7.49
Half Gallon (serves 12–15), 13.99
Gallon (serves 20–30), 26.99
Looking to take Der Dutchman to your next event? Download our Catering Menu to learn more. Discover more information on the Banquets, Catering & Wedding Receptions Tab.
Something warm, wonderful and homemade is always coming out of the oven in our bustling Amish kitchen, including apple cinnamon bread and fresh-made custard pie from Nettie Chupp, a Der Dutchman baker for more than 20 years.
ALL THINGS Orange
-
Orange Donuts
-
Orange Cranberry Bread
-
Orange Cranberry Muffins
-
Orange Cupcakes
-
Orange Cookies
-
Orange Cream Fudge
Specialty Cafe Drinks
Orange Blossom Honey Bear Latte
Pastries
Donuts
Glazed
Jelly-filled
Assorted Cake
–
Our Specialty
Long Johns
Apple Fritter
Honey Bun
Cinnamon Twist
–
Orders
Dozen
Half dozen
Muffins
Chocolate Chip
Banana Nut
Blueberry
Cranberry Nut
Lemon Poppyseed
Pumpkin Nut
Raisin Bran
Mini Muffins Available
Specialty Items
Cinnamon Roll
Pumpkin Roll
Chocolate Roll
Pecan Sticky Buns
Danish
Tea Rings
Pies
Regular Pies
Black Raspberry
Blueberry
Apple*
Dutch Apple
Cherry*
Peach
Custard
Pumpkin
Lemon Meringue
Key Lime
Rhubarb Crumb
–
Premium Pies
Pecan
Red Raspberry
Black Raspberry
–
Cream Pies
Banana
Chocolate
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Coconut
Peanut Butter
Butterscotch
–
Seasonal Pies
Fresh Strawberry
Fresh Summer Peach
Mince
*Available in No Sugar Added
Breads
Loaves
Whole Wheat**
White**
Cinnamon
Cinnamon Raisin
Apple Cinnamon
Raisin
Rye
Mulitgrain
Sourdough
Pumpkin~
Banana Nut~
Zuccinni~
Orange Cranberry~
Date Nut~
**Available in loaves and rolls
~Available in small and large loaves
Cookies
Chocolate Chip
Oatmeal Raisin
Chocolate Crinkle
Peanut Butter
Molasses
Snickerdoodle
Monster
Seasonal Cut-out Sugar
Shortbread with Jam filling
Coconut Crinkle
No-bake Cookies
Bar Cookies —
Brownies
Fudge Bars
Heavenly Bars
Pumpkin Bars
Cakes
Basic Flavors
Red Velvet
Marble
White
Chocolate
–
Specialty Flavors
Carrot
Coconut
German Chocolate
Italian Cream
Apple Butter Spice
White Rhapsody
Italian Cream
Mandarin Orange
Strawberry & Cream
Coffee Cake
Oatmeal Cake
Date Nut Cake
–
Icings & Fillings
Chocolate
Vanilla Buttercream
Cream Cheese
Whipped Cream
Cream
Mousse
Fruit Flavors
Cupcakes
Available in all cake flavors plus,
Orange
Key Lime
Piña Colada
Lemon
–
FUDGE
Made here in our bakery
Available by the pound or by the package
–
Ask about our Birthday & Wedding Cakes
Find Der Dutchman baked goods available at or served by these Sarasota area establishments. Find our partners
Amish Creamery
200 150th Ave
Madeira Beach, Florida
727-397-8222 | Website
Deans Produce
3535 Whitfield Ave
Sarasota, Florida
941-755-7100
Fruitville Grove
7410 Fruitville Rd
Sarasota, Florida
941-377-0896 | Website
Marathon
6212 S. Tamiami Trail
Sarasota, Florida
941-921-7441
Mobile
6290 Lake Osprey
Lakewood Ranch, Florida
941-907-3421
Perq Coffee Bar
1821 Hillview St. Sarasota, 34239
941-993-2265 | Website
Snow’s Country Market
6906 Lecanto Highway
Beverly Hills, Florida
352-489-4933 | Website
Sunfresh Market
3037 S McCall Rd
Englewood, Florida
941-475-7336 | Website
Texaco
19 E Rd
Sarasota, Florida
941-377-3262
The Sandbar Cafe
5800 Gaspirilla Rd
Boca Grande, Florida
941-964-0484
Yoder’s Marketplace
and Deli
8201 S Tamiami Tr, Unit 50
Sarasota, Florida
941- 922 9609
Special Occasion Cakes
Pre-order your special occasion cakes or select a ready-made one from our showcase. Our decorators can personalize your cake in minutes.
Available in layer cakes or sheetcakes. Stop in or call to place a cake order, 941-955-8007.
Siesta Key Beach is one of the biggest attractions in Sarasota, as is the gracious hospitality extended to groups of up to 300 at the Der Dutchman Restaurant. Here you’ll find the delicious tradition of scratch-made Amish recipes, along with a lovely and accommodating facility in our new Sun Room and Cafe.
Groups from 30 to 300 more can enjoy hot, freshly prepared foods quickly and efficiently to make the most of the time around the table.
For more information, please call 941-955-8007.
For many years, the quality and goodness known to Central Florida as Der Dutchman Restaurant has attracted patrons from far and wide. But you don’t have to travel to Sarasota to experience the simple pleasures of our authentic Amish Kitchen Cooking. We also offer full-service catering that delivers our delicious, made-from-scratch food directly to your business event, wedding reception, or special occasion, along with exceptional value and attentive service. Looking for the perfect venue? Book your next event at Carlisle Inn Sarasota and experience the same exceptional value and service you've come to trust.
Crowd-pleasing flavors
What makes the Der Dutchman catering experience so special? For starters, you can taste the tradition. The cooks in our kitchen use time-honored methods to create exactly the kind of simple, flavorful foods that lend themselves to feeding and satisfying a crowd.
Specially seasoned, all-natural meats roasted, broasted, and slow-cooked to tender perfection and served piping hot. Plates piled high with savory, made-from-scratch side dishes, like classic bread stuffing, real mashed potatoes and gravy, or homemade egg noodles. Slow-simmered soups, garden-fresh salads, and sandwiches made with just-baked breads and rolls. And there’s always a selection of our famous homemade pies and pastries, for a sweet finish from the Der Dutchman Bakery.
Options for every occasion
Our catering menu offers abundant options for bringing the delicious Der Dutchman experience to events of all types and sizes, day or night. The selection ranges from tasty appetizer platters and cheese trays to hearty boxed lunches, family-style meals, and, of course, our country buffets for breakfast, lunch, or dinner.
Whatever the event, our trained servers are there to set up the food table, assist during the meal, and take care of the details so the hosts can relax and enjoy the event knowing every guest is well taken care of.
Contact Der Dutchman Catering
We cater only from Monday to Saturday. Contact 941-955-8007 (extension 536) to inquire.
CATERED WEDDINGS
For your special day, you want a beautiful, gracious, comfortable facility to celebrate—and ours is just the place.
For more information, please call 941-955-8007 (extension 536).
wedding cakes
Pre-order your special occasion cakes or select a ready-made one from our showcase. Our decorators can personalize your cake in minutes.
Available in layer cakes or sheet cakes.
Contact WEDDING Catering
We cater only from Monday to Saturday. Contact 941-955-8007 (extension 536) to inquire.
For more information, please call 941-955-8007.
For more information, please call 419-866-7070.
Der Dutchman provides a friendly and warm welcome, beautiful surroundings, and a wholesome environment where church groups, local organizations, non-profits, and families can fellowship and feel well cared for.
Reviews and Comments from our Guests
"When I selected 'Excellent' in your survey, I really meant EXCELLENT! The food was amazing and many guests made a point to tell us how good they thought it was. We have leftovers that fed my extended family the day after and they were SO excited to have another helping. The servers were friendly and courteous - they worked quickly and efficiently so you barely noticed they were there. We cannot say enough great things about Der Dutchman's service."
–
"Thank you incredibly for helping make our wedding in December such a wonderful success! We loved the cake and the colors turned out so perfect. The food was delicious and our family definitely enjoyed the leftovers for days. There was a little anxiety planning a wedding across the country in such quick time, but every conversation, email and service provided by Der Dutchman was seamless, professional and warming!"
–
"The staff is awesome! They know exactly how much of each item to order per person so there is no waste and not lots of leftovers which keeps our price within budget."
–
"Lynnette was the key contact throughout the planning of our event. She always responded promptly in our emails during the planning process. I appreciated several phone calls she made to me to firm up the many details. I felt very confident that the outcome of our wedding reception would be exactly as discussed, and it was. In fact, it exceeded my expectations!"
–
"Lynnette Haskins was a dream to work with. In planning my events she knew exactly how much food I needed and was right on the money with no waste. The chicken marsala is awesome and I wish that she would put that on the menu along with the potatoes and gravy that are out of this world. Thank you for the consistency of excellent service and food!"
–
"Great recommendations and able to accommodate us at the last minute. Food arrived hot and fresh. Thank you for another great employee lunch enjoyed by our staff!"
DER DUTCHMAN RESTAURANT & BAKERY
Summer Hours: May–Oct
Monday–Saturday: 7am–8pm
Sunday: Closed
Winter Hours: Nov–April
Monday–Thursday: 6am–8pm
Friday–Saturday: 6am–9pm
Sunday: Closed
Carlisle Gifts
Summer Hours: May–Oct
Monday–Saturday: 8am–8pm
Sunday: Closed
Winter Hours: Nov–April
Monday–Thursday: 8am–8pm
Friday–Saturday: 8am–9pm
Sunday: Closed
NEw Year's Day
Closed
Memorial Day
7am–7pm
JULY 4
7am–3pm
Labor Day
7am–7pm
Thanksgiving Eve
6am–8pm
THANKSGIVING DAY
11am–5pm
Buffet only
CHRISTMAS EVE 2019
6am to 2pm
CHRISTMAS DAY 2019
Closed
NEW YEAR'S EVE 2019
6am to 7pm
NEW YEAR'S day 2020
7am to 7pm