Search
Menu

Dine-in & Carry-out Available!

Der Dutchman Sarasota, Florida

Select a section:
Menus

BAKERY

Something warm, wonderful and homemade is always coming out of the oven in our bustling Amish kitchen, including apple cinnamon bread and fresh-made custard pie from Nettie Chupp, a Der Dutchman baker for more than 20 years.

Christmas Cookie Trays

Christmas Cookie Trays

Trays include Christmas cut-outs, peanut butter blossoms, chocolate crinkle, Russian tea balls, and thumbprint cookies. If you prefer all iced cut-outs instead of the assortment, please let us know when you order.

Small Tray – $15.29
1 dozen cookies

Medium Tray – $25.99
2 dozen cookies

Large Tray – $36.99
3 dozen cookies

Extra Large Tray – $48.99
4½ dozen cookies

Christmas Cookie Trays

Call 941-955-8007 to order!

Seasonal Bakery Specials

Seasonal SpecialS

Cranberry-orange Bread

Cranberry Muffins

Cranberry Walnut Fudge

Pumpkin Cranberry Pancakes

Cranberry Walnut Salad

 

All things pumpkin still available!

Specialty Cafe Drinks

Peppermint Mocha Latte

 

 

Bakery Menu
Bakery Menu Download

Pastries

Donuts

Glazed
Jelly-filled
Assorted Cake

–

Our Specialty

Long Johns
Apple Fritter
Honey Bun
Cinnamon Twist

–

Orders

Dozen
Half dozen

 

Muffins

Chocolate Chip
Banana Nut
Blueberry
Cranberry Nut
Lemon Poppyseed
Pumpkin Nut
Raisin Bran

Mini Muffins Available

 

Specialty Items

Cinnamon Roll
Pumpkin Roll
Chocolate Roll
Pecan Sticky Buns
Danish
Tea Rings

Pies

Regular Pies

Black Raspberry
Blueberry
Apple*
Dutch Apple
Cherry*
Peach
Custard
Pumpkin
Lemon Meringue
Key Lime
Rhubarb Crumb

–

Premium Pies

Pecan
Red Raspberry
Black Raspberry

–

Cream Pies

Banana
Chocolate
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Coconut
Peanut Butter
Butterscotch

–

Seasonal Pies

Fresh Strawberry
Fresh Summer Peach
Mince

*Available in No Sugar Added

Breads

Loaves

Whole Wheat**
White**
Cinnamon
Cinnamon Raisin
Apple Cinnamon
Raisin
Rye
Mulitgrain
Sourdough
Pumpkin~
Banana Nut~
Zuccinni~
Orange Cranberry~
Date Nut~

**Available in loaves and rolls
~Available in small and large loaves

 

Cookies

Chocolate Chip
Oatmeal Raisin
Chocolate Crinkle
Peanut Butter
Molasses
Snickerdoodle
Monster
Seasonal Cut-out Sugar
Shortbread with Jam filling
Coconut Crinkle
No-bake Cookies

Bar Cookies —
Brownies
Fudge Bars
Heavenly Bars
Pumpkin Bars

Cakes

Basic Flavors

Red Velvet
Marble
White
Chocolate

–

Specialty Flavors

Carrot
Coconut
German Chocolate
Italian Cream
Apple Butter Spice
White Rhapsody
Italian Cream
Mandarin Orange
Strawberry & Cream
Coffee Cake
Oatmeal Cake
Date Nut Cake

–

Icings & Fillings

Chocolate
Vanilla Buttercream
Cream Cheese
Whipped Cream
Cream
Mousse
Fruit Flavors

 

Cupcakes

Available in all cake flavors plus,
Orange
Key Lime
Piña Colada
Lemon

–

FUDGE

Made here in our bakery
Available by the pound or by the package

–

Ask about our Birthday & Wedding Cakes

Bakery Partners

Find Der Dutchman baked goods available at or served by these Sarasota area establishments. Find our partners

 

Amish Creamery

200 150th Ave
Madeira Beach, Florida

727-397-8222 | Website


 
Deans Produce
3535 Whitfield Ave
Sarasota, Florida

941-755-7100

 

Fruitville Grove

7410 Fruitville Rd
Sarasota, Florida 
941-377-0896 | Website

 

Marathon

6212 S. Tamiami Trail
Sarasota, Florida
941-921-7441

 

Mobile

6290 Lake Osprey
Lakewood Ranch, Florida
941-907-3421

 

Perq Coffee Bar
1821 Hillview St. Sarasota, 34239
941-993-2265 | Website

 

Snow’s Country Market

6906 Lecanto Highway
Beverly Hills, Florida
352-489-4933 | Website

 

Sunfresh Market

3037 S McCall Rd
Englewood, Florida 
941-475-7336 | Website

 

Texaco

19 E Rd
Sarasota, Florida
941-377-3262

 

The Sandbar Cafe

5800 Gaspirilla Rd
Boca Grande, Florida
941-964-0484

 

Yoder’s Marketplace
and Deli
8201 S Tamiami Tr, Unit 50
Sarasota, Florida 

941- 922 9609

Birthday, Anniversary & Wedding Cakes

Special Occasion Cakes

Pre-order your special occasion cakes or select a ready-made one from our showcase. Our decorators can personalize your cake in minutes.

  • Birthday
  • Anniversary
  • Wedding
  • Bridal and Baby Showers
  • Retirement
  • Reunions
  • Graduation

Available in layer cakes or sheetcakes. Stop in or call to place a cake order, 941-955-8007.

BANQUETS, CATERING, WEDDING RECEPTIONS

Banquets
GROUP-FRIENDLY OPTIONS

Groups from 30 to 300 more can enjoy hot, freshly prepared foods quickly and efficiently to make the most of the time around the table.

  • Located a short drive from shopping and Siesta Key Beach
  • Choose country breakfast, lunch or dinner buffets or family-style dinner
  • All Amish Country Kitchen meals include homemade baked goods fresh from our bakery ovens
  • Year-round, indoor/outdoor seating featuring two-sided fireplace and seating for 68
  • Fast, efficient, crowd-pleasing service
  • Smoke-free facilities
  • No advance deposit required

For more information, please call 941-955-8007.

Sarasota Banquets (pdf)
Off-site Catering

For many years, the quality and goodness known to Central Florida as Der Dutchman Restaurant has attracted patrons from far and wide. But you don’t have to travel to Sarasota to experience the simple pleasures of our authentic Amish Kitchen Cooking. We also offer full-service catering that delivers our delicious, made-from-scratch food directly to your business event, wedding reception, or special occasion, along with exceptional value and attentive service. Looking for the perfect venue? Book your next event at Carlisle Inn Sarasota and experience the same exceptional value and service you've come to trust.

Crowd-pleasing flavors

What makes the Der Dutchman catering experience so special? For starters, you can taste the tradition. The cooks in our kitchen use time-honored methods to create exactly the kind of simple, flavorful foods that lend themselves to feeding and satisfying a crowd.

Specially seasoned, all-natural meats roasted, broasted, and slow-cooked to tender perfection and served piping hot. Plates piled high with savory, made-from-scratch side dishes, like classic bread stuffing, real mashed potatoes and gravy, or homemade egg noodles. Slow-simmered soups, garden-fresh salads, and sandwiches made with just-baked breads and rolls. And there’s always a selection of our famous homemade pies and pastries, for a sweet finish from the Der Dutchman Bakery.
 

Options for every occasion

Our catering menu offers abundant options for bringing the delicious Der Dutchman experience to events of all types and sizes, day or night. The selection ranges from tasty appetizer platters and cheese trays to hearty boxed lunches, family-style meals, and, of course, our country buffets for breakfast, lunch, or dinner.

Whatever the event, our trained servers are there to set up the food table, assist during the meal, and take care of the details so the hosts can relax and enjoy the event knowing every guest is well taken care of.

 

Contact Der Dutchman Catering

We cater only from Monday to Saturday. Contact 941-955-8007 (extension 536) to inquire.

Sarasota Catering (pdf)
Wedding Receptions

CATERED WEDDINGS

For your special day, you want a beautiful, gracious, comfortable facility to celebrate—and ours is just the place.

  • Full-service catering from Der Dutchman includes from-scratch food, plus set up, clean up, elegant disposable dinnerware, linens, cake table, and fast, friendly service
  • Minimum order of $360 required, 25% non-refundable deposit and 18% service fee apply
  • Free delivery within 30 miles

For more information, please call 941-955-8007 (extension 536).

 

cakes

Pre-order your special occasion cakes or select a ready-made one from our showcase. Our decorators can personalize your cake in minutes.

  • Birthday
  • Anniversary
  • Wedding
  • Bridal and Baby Showers
  • Retirement
  • Reunions
  • Graduation

Available in layer cakes or sheet cakes.

 

Contact WEDDING Catering

We cater only from Monday to Saturday. Contact 941-955-8007 (extension 536) to inquire.

 

 

 

Sarasota Wedding Receptions (pdf) Sarasota Cakes (pdf)
Motor Coach Groups
TOUR-FRIENDLY EXTRAS
Our reasonable prices and long list of amenities make this an easy way to experience the simple pleasures of the Pinecraft area of Sarasota.
  • Easy, no-step access
  • Ample, free bus parking
  • Free meal and bakery item for driver and escort
  • Clean, convenient restrooms
  • Spacious dining rooms

For more information, please call 941-955-8007.

Sarasota Banquets (pdf)
Corporate and Business Meetings
SPACIOUS AND CONVENIENT
From high-profile conferences to simple business lunches, Der Dutchman Restaurant or our Conference Center offers the ideal location for your corporate or business meetings.
  • Audio/video capabilities, flip charts and Internet access
  • A wide range of banquet options featuring the Amish kitchen cooking from Der Dutchman Restaurant
  • Our conference center can accommodate groups of 30 to 300
  • Fast, friendly service accommodates even large groups for hot lunch
  • Choose from bountiful breakfast buffets, box lunches, and elegant banquets
  • Alcoholic beverages not served or permitted in meeting rooms or public areas

For more information, please call 419-866-7070.

 

Community and Family
FAMILY-FRIENDLY ENVIRONMENT

Der Dutchman provides a friendly and warm welcome, beautiful surroundings, and a wholesome environment where church groups, local organizations, non-profits, and families can fellowship and feel well cared for.

  • Friendly, efficient service
  • Good value
  • High standards for quality and consistency
  • Non-smoking facilities
  • No alcoholic beverages
  • Ample free parking
  • Full handicapped accessibility
  • Activities and amenities for all ages
Sarasota Banquets (pdf)
What others say about our Catering & Banquets

Reviews and Comments from our Guests

"When I selected 'Excellent' in your survey, I really meant EXCELLENT! The food was amazing and many guests made a point to tell us how good they thought it was. We have leftovers that fed my extended family the day after and they were SO excited to have another helping. The servers were friendly and courteous - they worked quickly and efficiently so you barely noticed they were there. We cannot say enough great things about Der Dutchman's service."

–

"Thank you incredibly for helping make our wedding in December such a wonderful success! We loved the cake and the colors turned out so perfect. The food was delicious and our family definitely enjoyed the leftovers for days. There was a little anxiety planning a wedding across the country in such quick time, but every conversation, email and service provided by Der Dutchman was seamless, professional and warming!"

–

"The staff is awesome! They know exactly how much of each item to order per person so there is no waste and not lots of leftovers which keeps our price within budget."

–

"Lynnette was the key contact throughout the planning of our event. She always responded promptly in our emails during the planning process. I appreciated several phone calls she made to me to firm up the many details. I felt very confident that the outcome of our wedding reception would be exactly as discussed, and it was. In fact, it exceeded my expectations!"

–

"Lynnette Haskins was a dream to work with. In planning my events she knew exactly how much food I needed and was right on the money with no waste. The chicken marsala is awesome and I wish that she would put that on the menu along with the potatoes and gravy that are out of this world. Thank you for the consistency of excellent service and food!"

–

"Great recommendations and able to accommodate us at the last minute. Food arrived hot and fresh. Thank you for another great employee lunch enjoyed by our staff!"

 

wide.jpg

DIRECTIONS

From I-275 (St. Petersburg)
Take Exit 210 toward Sarasota/St Armands. Merge onto Fruitville Road then turn left onto McIntosh Road. Turn right onto Bahia Vista Street. Der Dutchman is located on the right.
Der Dutchman Restaurant & Bakery
3713 Bahia Vista St
Sarasota, FL 34232
941-955-8007
Carlisle Gifts
3713 Bahia Vista St
Sarasota, FL 34232
941-955-4009

View Google Map
From the North from I-75 (Tampa)
From I-75, take Exit 210 toward Sarasota/St Armands. Merge onto Fruitville Rd then turn left onto Beneva Rd. Turn left onto Bahia Vista Street. Der Dutchman is located on the left, 800 feet from the intersection.
Der Dutchman Restaurant & Bakery
3713 Bahia Vista St
Sarasota, FL 34232
941-955-8007
Carlisle Gifts
3713 Bahia Vista St
Sarasota, FL 34232
941-955-4009

View Google Map
From the South from I-75 (Naples, Miami)
Take exit 207 to Bee Ridge Road. Turn left onto Bee Ridge Road. Turn right onto McIntosh Road. Turn left onto Bahia Vista Street. Der Dutchman is located on the right.
Der Dutchman Restaurant & Bakery
3713 Bahia Vista St
Sarasota, FL 34232
941-955-8007
Carlisle Gifts
3713 Bahia Vista St
Sarasota, FL 34232
941-955-4009

View Google Map

HOURS

Hours

Regular hours:

Restaurant Dine-In, Carry-out & Delivery
Monday–Saturday: 8am–7pm
Breakfast Every Day!

Bakery
Monday–Saturday: 7am–7pm

Closed Sunday

Holiday hours:

NEw Year's Day
7am-7pm

Good Friday - April 10
6am-8pm

Memorial Day
8am–7pm

JULY 4
7am–3pm

Labor Day
7am–7pm

Thanksgiving Eve
6am–8pm

THANKSGIVING DAY
11am–5pm
Serving buffet only

 

CHRISTMAS EVE
6am-2pm

CHRISTMAS DAY
Closed

NEW YEAR'S EVE
6am-7pm

Fundraising
Sell our dough, pies and cake rolls for your cause.
See Details
Wholesale Bakery
Become a Der Dutchman Bakery Distributor.
See Details
TRIP ADVISOR
See what others have to say about their visit.
VIEW RATING
Sports Team Special
Sports Team Specials
Special buffet pricing for visiting teams.
View Menu
thumb_birdhouse.jpg
Timeless Treasures
Discover the art of ‘the find.’
Learn More
Chicken Dinner
Catering
Delicious Der Dutchman meals
brought to your event.
Learn more